Multi-culture-shock in Shelbyville, Tennessee
Jerry Gordon at The New English Review writes a fascinating article of multi-culture-shock. It’s really a case study of what happens when a tribal community of Muslims find their way to a small-town community of Tennessee. The Enlightenment ideal of pluralism is one thing. The 21st century reality of it is another. The article is an interview with Brian Mosely, a writer for the small newspaper of the small town of Shelbyville, Tennessee. He’s spent a long time covering the Somali community who was brought in by Tyson Chicken to work in the factory. He said this when asked about the difficulties of such an arrangement:
There are so many difficulties; it’s hard to know where to begin. At the top of the list would have to be the attitude of the Somali refugees, which locals have consistently described as ‘rude and demanding’. This description comes from practically everyone who have encountered or interacted with them, from your average convenience store clerk all the way to law enforcement officers and other officials.
Given that this area of Tennessee is known for their southern hospitality, the behavior of the Somalis has really angered many people in the community, even those who would typically welcome people from other cultures. But what is really infuriating many residents are that the groups who bring the Somalis into the country appear to expect the local community to practice the same type of moral and cultural relativism they do.
For example, when asked about the ‘rude and arrogant’ behavior, the head of Catholic Charities said that ‘this is just the Western perception of the Somali culture.’ She claimed that since the Somalis have been refugees for so long, it is only through being rude and demanding that they have managed to get the little they have gotten to survive over the years in the camp.” However, these types of explanations have not been well received here at all. I hear a lot of variations on the phrase, ‘when in Rome…’ from the public, although many others have been quite a bit more direct about expressing their feelings.
It gets worse. They don’t seem to like firefighters, police officers, and female school administrators, among others.














Click to Print
Include Comments











back to top59 Comments to “Multi-culture-shock in Shelbyville, Tennessee”
Is this sort of thing why you wish to repeal the Enlightenment, Harrison?
Report comment to moderator
I’m wondering about the reason(s) for this post..
Report comment to moderator
Odd how Harrison didn’t quote the next two paragraphs after the one he did quote. I’m sure it was just an oversight. They say:
Then there is the issue of religion. Bedford County has an extremely strong Christian faith and the sudden introduction of hundreds of Muslims into this small southern town has resulted in a massive culture shock. For the past 30 years, the predominate image of Muslims seen in mass media are of the ones yelling ‘death to America’ and blowing themselves up. Suddenly, they are in line with grandma at Wal-Mart. The Somalis began to move to this area just a short time after 9/11 and the release of the DVD of ‘Black Hawk Down,’ which doesn’t exactly portray them in a favorable light. As a result, there is a tremendous amount of fear in some parts of the community due to this perception. I have also heard many opinions of disgust and disbelief that our own government would let these people in here. Anger from members of the public over the issue of illegal immigration is already high in this community and the introduction of the Somalis has only made these feelings much worse.
Just this week, one of our other reporters came back from an assignment and passed on a compliment of our series, stating that this unnamed businessman told him that “I don’t like those Muslims. I don’t trust them.” These statements came from a Hispanic immigrant.
But of course, the troubles are all the fault of the Somalis, in Harrison’s world.
Report comment to moderator
The purpose of this post is to show that there is a dark side to all this multiculturalism and diversity crap. It is time to stand up to these predatory cultures who come in and exploit the freedom and tolerance they find here.
Report comment to moderator
Dittos Manxman! They should all be sent to England where they can be welcomed by the Anglican Archbishop. Barring that, we should send all the adult able-bodied males BACK to Somalia and instruct them to liberate their homeland a la the Bay of Pigs in Cuba.
Only this time let these freedom fighters win!
Report comment to moderator
That is an excellent article and interview. Thanks for directing us to it.
Culture shock is huge. Just taking a person from say, rural Idaho to a bagle shop in New York is shocking and I am certain the reverse is equally true. The fear of the locals based on years of limited news reports mingled with the way of life brought with the newcomers would be very challenging. And then a bit of isolationism on the part of both sides would only add to the pain. I think they are on the right track by trying to open dialogue and if they could get one local family to sponser one new family until everyone was covered, they would see great stride on understanding and compassion. It took some time to learn to not flush toilet paper in Greece.
Report comment to moderator
You’re not supposed to flush toilet paper in Greece because it’s too greecy! Ho Ho Ho and a bottle of dang ol’ rum! Heh heh. Dude!
Report comment to moderator
I should have guessed that an American charitable person would claim that the rudeness and arrogant behaviour of these Somali refugees was really just faulty Western perception and that the normally hospitable southern bread Tennesseans were to blame for any problems that have arisen from allowing these refugees to plunked into their awfully faulty town by Tyson Foods to do work that Americans, of course, won’t do.
Report comment to moderator
SteveG, Would you want this to happen to your hometown?
Report comment to moderator
I am close to a community of Liberian refugees in Minnesota. So close that I am considered part of this community as their pastor. Our church has embraced this first-generation community with huge cultural differences and this has enriched our family. Some barely escaped Liberia with their lives. Som stayed in refugee camps for up to 4 years in the Ivory Coast before coming to the USA. Some saw their loved ones beheaded in their home-country.
I have done many weddings for them. I have held funerals for them, even though the body of the loved one could not be sent from Liberia. I have wept and laughed with them and counseled them often.
These African refugees are super hard workers. They are good learners. They are NOT complainers. They contribute! They give. There are major cultural differences, but they have nothing but respect for our culture, our community and our way of life in Minnesota (and we respect theirs).
Their gratitude for being in America overflows and surpasses that of most any other American citizen I know.
They are authentic Christians and that is huge.
Report comment to moderator
If you will read the entire article all this guy is saying is that these people should have been given some instruction in American culture before being plopped down and deserted. It is up to the new people to adapt not the other way around.
Report comment to moderator
We shouldn’t make too much of the fact that these complaints are coming from genteel Southerners. I grew up on a farm and I’ve lived in more than one small town, so I have quite a bit of experience with the type of kindness expressed by rural folks (albeit not in “the South”). It would be better described as a polite veneer than as genuine love or kindness. I’m not saying the Somalis should be excused, but I imagine that if anything, rural Southern expectations are making this harder for everyone involved rather than smoothing things along.
Report comment to moderator
In a sobering article about the difficulties of immigrants who can’t seem to adjust, here’s a great line that had me laughing:
Report comment to moderator
There is no excuse for being rude and demanding, no matter who you are. Rudeness doesn’t wear well even if you are rich, clean, and handsome. Rudeness certainly won’t help your case at all if you’re poor, smelly, and have strange cultural habits…
Report comment to moderator
#12. I was waiting fot that one.
Report comment to moderator
It is up to the new people to adapt not the other way around.
Amen!
Report comment to moderator
From the original post:
“The head of Catholic Charities said that ‘this is just the Western perception of the Somali culture.’ She claimed that since the Somalis have been refugees for so long, it is only through being rude and demanding that they have managed to get the little they have gotten to survive over the years in the camp.”
This is a wrong-headed spin, borne of too much time in academia, perhaps. Cultural gaps do call for lots of patience and understanding on all sides. But they don’t call for excuses for anyone being ‘rude or demanding’ on either side.
I know people well who lived in such camps, for years. And they are among the LEAST rude or demanding people on this planet!
The spin in the quote above reminds me of the sensitive posture toward crime that presumes that poverty causes crime. Not as a rule. It may feel that way, but I think it is more true to say that crime causes poverty. Nothing impoverishes a community more that subjecting it to chaos and a criminal atmosphere of taking what you want and mistrusting those who have anything. Some of the least criminal people on earth (and throughout history) are also very poor.
It’s character!
Report comment to moderator
Outkast,
It is up to the newbies to adapt, but in my experience that is much more easily done if somebody from the local culture reaches out, comes alongside, and offers instruction in the day to day running of things. It is much easier to remain in an insulated cocoon of ones fellow expats than to step into the new life without any sign the residents want to see you succeed. When they are all standing around gawking, waiting to see you do something they consider stupid (picking out ones’ own veggies in a fruit market for example), it is much more comfortable to get some companions from “your own set” and pretend life is like back home.
As far as rude and demanding, I have yet to run into a culture I did not view as rude and demanding before I got to know them. That includes those people in the bagle store in New York.
Report comment to moderator
Well I see the Christian attitude of love, charity and compassion is flowing as always.
“It is up to them to adjust,” Jesus said. “Or they should go back where they came from, their predatory cultures.”
KBells … it does happen and people have to adjust. My hometown already is fairly diverse ethnically and culturally.
Here we see Harrison selectively quoting to argue that the problems Shelbyville is experiencing are all the fault of the “rude and demanding” Somalis. In the parts of the article he didn’t highlight, we learn that part of the problem is the suspicion and prejudice of the people in the town.
This is a real problem without an easy solution, but to suggest it’s all the fault of the outsiders is just playing to prejudice. These are legal immigrants, and they have the right to be somewhere in America.
Report comment to moderator
The interview in its entirety was really enlightening, but found little in the way of conclusions. Certainly the cultural divides must be bridged, but how? Another ginormous federal bureaucracy: the Dept. of Cultural Assimilation & Education?
In most cases, the second generation of any immigrant population are the ones who adapt more quickly and assimilate more fully. So the most encouraging part of this story is how the education system in Tennessee already had significant ESL resources that could be redirected toward the children of the refugees. Mom and Dad may never fully come around, but when Junior gets a more complete immersion (through school) and probably a more significant education than his parents ever got, that’s when the current problems will fade.
Report comment to moderator
RobHays, you said and I copied (I am really quite proud of myself for that!):
Certainly the cultural divides must be bridged, but how? Another ginormous federal bureaucracy: the Dept. of Cultural Assimilation & Education
My suggestion? People acting like the warm welcoming helpful beings they can be.
Report comment to moderator
SteveG – 19, wrote; “Well I see the Christian attitude of love, charity and compassion is flowing as always.”
And I see it at my curch all the time (literally, “as always”), SteveG, including with African refugees and us Mid-Westerners. You are welcome any time.
It is indeed up to them to adjust AND it is up to us to reach out and help them adjust. It’s a two-way street or we get nowhere.
But it is not up to the host culture to abolish her culture and heritage for the sake of any newcomer that refuses to adjust. We have something awesome here in the USA and we fail each other and we fail newcomers if we do not recognize the wonderful Western legacy we have here and work to keep it healthy and functional–for each other and for newcomers.
Report comment to moderator
My take on it is this: how come Tyson Foods has to go to Somalia to get workers? I thought there were plenty of Americans willing to do this work?
If the locals don’t like them, then they should have taken away the Somalis’ job opportunities: work for Tyson or if they have a job, get a friend or family member to apply.
The Somalis, like many other peoples before them, will have a hard time adjusting. Their children will adjust much more easier. And their granchildren will be Americans, pure and simple.
This recipe has been repeated for each and every culture, nationality or ethnic group to come to this country.
Report comment to moderator
Sadly, I have to agree with Rostin. Too many times, when a white southerner calls somebody like the Somalis “rude and demanding”, what they really mean is “not deferent to me like normal black people”
Report comment to moderator
As an American who lives overseas, I read stuff like this and just shake my head.
I am somewhat proficient in the language of my home overseas, but nowhere near fluent. At times I don’t know the right way to respond to things people say to me, so I know I come across as rude, even though I don’t intend to be.
There are other things when my adopted culture and city drives me crazy: the way people seem like they are yelling when they are only talking, the way they drive, the street dogs, the dirt. I slip at times into the “ugly American” mindset (hopefully not too much).
The problem in Shelbyville goes two ways. Yes, the Somalis need to adapt and change, and they may be slow to do so. Give them some grace. Yes, they are Moslems. Give them some grace. Don’t look at the speck in their eyes if you have a plank in your own. More than people in many parts of the world, Americans can live in isolation from other cultures, and when people from a different culture come in, the locals have a hard time adapting as well. It grieves me when the perception is that it is the Christians who have the hardest time showing love and grace to immigrants.
I’m not arguing for multi-culturalism or for open borders. But the neighbor who is near you is your neighbor, even if he is a Somali Moslem.
Grace and Peace
Report comment to moderator
Joel Mark at #22: SteveG – 19, wrote; “Well I see the Christian attitude of love, charity and compassion is flowing as always.”
And I see it at my curch all the time (literally, “as always”), SteveG, including with African refugees and us Mid-Westerners. You are welcome any time.
Sometimes when I say things like I did at #19, I wonder if I’m being unfair. And maybe I am … but why do Christians not go first for the reaction of “how can I make these recent arrivals feel welcome”? rather than “It’s up to them to be like us, we don’t have to do a darn thing?”
I realize most Christians are not like that, but look at comments 4, 5, 8, 14, 15 and 16 along with HSK’s original post. Maybe it’s just me, but it’s not the response I think Jesus would have.
These cultural issues are not easy to fix, but I don’t see how it helps to try to fix the blame solely on either the immigrants or the people of their new home.
Report comment to moderator
I live in Nashville, a city mentioned heavily here, because so many immigrants come through here. I understand that we have the second-highest number of Kurds of any city in the world. I have two families of ‘em on my street, one just across the street.
I’ve gotten to know them a bit; most of my other neighbors haven’t. They’re polite and friendly, with limited English. Some real cultural adaptations for me, though–when I go over to their house for anything, I’m expected to come in and eat whatever food is available. And as an American who’s a picky eater, even without knowing what’s in the food, I find it distasteful enough that I have a hard time not throwing up. Last time I went I actually was invited to join them for supper, and I sat down with them (on the floor), but I was really glad to be able to tell them I had just eaten and so I wasn’t very hungry. I forced myself to eat some, but it took real effort, since it was gagging me, and then she sent my leftovers home with me.
But this family is struggling financially, and I know that it’s real generosity for them to give me food, and not their fault if it’s something I can’t stand! (And for all their reputation of being unfriendly to women, I was super impressed one day by this: The wife of the family next door is the one who mows the lawn. The lawn mower was having trouble one day, so she turned it off and looked at it. The man from across the street came and looked at the mower, took care of the problem, and insisted on mowing the rest of her lawn.)
Report comment to moderator
Yep, the newbies have to adjust. Yes I am positively sure that these Catholic helpers taught the newbies local customs, made them aware of local sensitivities, counciled them to act a certian way in order to fit in well. But, they still acted arrogant and rude enough to have the Catholic helpers make excuses for them and blame the innocent.
Not quite the same tale as Joel Mark’s is it.
My point stands. Blaming the locals for not being understanding because of their faulty Western culture is quite PC and very anti American Whack Jobbish.
Report comment to moderator
#24. Read the full article. It’s convenient to blame racism for the attitudes expressed, but the reality is more complex. When an apartment complex is on fire, and the residents refuse to evacuate and tell the fire department to go away because they aren’t welcome, that’s rude no matter what your skin color is.
Report comment to moderator
One of the blessings of living in America is that we can generally trust our city employees: police, fire, etc. That is not necessarily true in all countries. Ideally, when your apartment complex is ablaze, you will know the fire folk are there to help. In some countries, they are there to shoot you as you come out of the building. Or the folk in the building may have been jerks, I am trying to give the benefit of the doubt.
Report comment to moderator
Llama 28,
And when we were in the military, we always got briefings and classes on culture. Helpful but not the same as your neighbor down the street inviting you over and showing you how to eat the local cuisine while being friendly and welcoming.
Report comment to moderator
My point stands. Blaming the locals for not being understanding because of their faulty Western culture is quite PC and very anti American Whack Jobbish.
What’s anti-American (God I am starting to hate that phrase and the mindless way it’s used to mean “anything I the conservative don’t agree with”) is to have the Statue of Liberty proclaiming “Send us your tired, your poor, your hungry, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free” and mentally adding “but not to my town.”
Report comment to moderator
If you want to stem the problems with immigrant Somalis like these, you need to axe the Reagan shamnesty law, which allowed all sorts of bad people to come here because their home government was “oppressing” them.
It seems to me that if you want to address this problem, change the law.
Then, you have to address those already in this country. If I’m Shelbyville, I’d get the Christian churches more involved in doing charity work – Protestant Christians outnumber Catholics in the South, so they need to get involved.
You need to crack down on the gangs and drugs and other problems the Somalis bring with them.
Llama – am I reading you correctly: you see Catholic Charities as a co-conspirator in this issue or something?
If so, I say you should lobby your church to belly up and help take care of the immigrants that Reagan decided to let in.
Also, go reread what she said. She answered a specific question. I’d blame the reporter rather than her. We have no idea what he asked and in what context.
Never trust journalists, especially those who won’t print the whole question involved. They are hiding something.
Report comment to moderator
One doesn’t have to be a PC liberal to see that much of this is simple bigotry. I’m not saying that everyone who has problems with the Somali immigrants is a bigot, but a lot of them probably are.
“They proved that even in this age nationalism stands under God and that it is a sin against him and his call for fellowship with other nations if it degenerates into national egotism and greed.” — from the memoir/preface to The Cost of Discipleship by Dietrich Bonhoeffer
Report comment to moderator
The reporter isn’t putting all the blame on the Somali refugees. He is asking why the people who dumped them there didn’t prepare them a little better or at least hang around and help them out. That is not the job of the people of Shelbyville.
Also, It not just a matter of rudeness and culture, it is a matter of respect for authority.
“Law enforcement reports a similar ‘lack of respect’ for their authority
the Somalis have difficulties with women in supervisory roles and nearly half of the principals in our schools are female. It has been reported to us that the refugees have no respect for these educators.
The administrator for the Sheriff Department told me ‘they are a hard people to deal with,’ and noted that Somalis have not adapted to American culture or laws, pointing out that officers would pull them over and “you tell them what they did was wrong, but they’ll say they were right.” It is the total lack of respect for the rules and law enforcement that have rubbed officers the wrong way.”
Report comment to moderator
Hi SteveG,
Happy Xenophobia day. I look forward to it every black history month!
Report comment to moderator
P.S. –
Back when I used to work in retail in tourist heavy San Francisco, you who I thought were always really rude? The English! Just straight up rude, by our practices.
Then I kind of checked myself, remembered that my degree in rhetoric included basic communication theory, and chilled out because the women I was serving weren’t being rude, they were just being English and they talk differently from me. After that I could appreciate their directness and honesty, and found my American customers’ polite lies equally frustrating and insincere.
Back when I used to work in retail in tourist heavy San Francisco, you who I thought were always really rude? The English! Just straight up rude, by our practices.
Then I kind of checked myself, remembered that my degree in rhetoric included basic communication theory, and chilled out because the American women I was serving weren’t being insincere, they were just being American.
It was a little trip in getting over Xenophobia!
Report comment to moderator
Frankly, it is the responsibility of the immigrants to adjust. I’m an American currently studying in France, and daily I have to recognize that if anyone changes, it has to be me. I tried escargot for the first time tonight in the presence of a Frenchwoman who prepared them just for me…quite the cultural experience. I’ve learned how to ask directions on the street and how to get a smile out of the cafe worker. The double-cheek greeting kiss is becoming almost natural. I’ve developed a thick skin for comments about my country, my accent, and my lack of language skills, and my Christianity. I had never been cursed at so many times in my life until I came to France (although it was another American doing most of the cursing.)
That said, I admit that my situation is easier than these immigrants. I live with a native family who is very supportive and had cultural training before I left through my home university. But the burden isn’t on the French to welcome me, it is I who must take the first step (as Monsieur the directer reminded us today.) If we students here don’t make any friends, it’s probably our fault for not making any efforts.
SteveG, I agree that Christians should be welcoming these immigrants with open arms. I definitely have been here in France, and I’ve seen they give the same welcome to nonbelievers. You’re right, Christians have a special duty in this regard.
At the same time, if the Somalis are planning to stay in the country for a few years or permanently, it’s really up to them to adapt to function in the US culture. And yes, it’s going to be hard for them, and we should hope that their neighbors will be welcoming and helpful. But that doesn’t negate the fact that they have most of the responsibility for integration and installation into the community.
Report comment to moderator
As for the people of Shelbyville, they are probably ordinary working class people whose only knowledge of Somali is the movie “Black Hawk Down” and now they are suddenly expected to be missionaries and diplomats. Has any effort been made by Tyson or Immigration or whoever to educate them on what to expect.
Report comment to moderator
It doesn’t hurt the newbies to adjust, and I never said (nor implied) that it’s not the job of Christians to help them adjust. I would expect SteveG to take my comment out of context, but not Mumsee. Oh well.
Report comment to moderator
Sylvie,
Agreed. When entering another country, one must be prepared for differences and attempt to follow not only the law of the land but the courtesies of the land. But, like you said, having a local prepare it sure helps the snail go down.
Outcast,
Simply expanding on the idea that we as believers have a responsibility of hospitality. And life would be easier all around if the locals attempted to help the new ones adapt. Of course, it is the responsibility of the immigrant to adapt to the gaining country.
Report comment to moderator
Outkast! And I thought were bonding before over Gene Eugene and Steve Taylor!
KBells, I fully agree that it sounds like the people on both sides should have been better prepared for the experience. I also fully agree that people from other cultures who want to be first-generation immigrants here have an obligation to get along with the locals, even if that means learning new attitudes and new ways to do things.
What I don’t agree with is those people who say they should “be sent back to where they came from” if they’re here legally, (#4 and #5 unless #5 was meant as sarcasm, which I’m not sure of), and those who view the strangers with suspicion and hostility and then blame them for causing any tension in relations rather than take the first step to bridging the differences.
Report comment to moderator
“It is up to the new people to adapt not the other way around.”
AND
“But the burden isn’t on the French to welcome me, it is I who must take the first step (as Monsieur the directer reminded us today.)”
Of course because the Levitical Purity codes command foreigners I your country to be nice to you!
And the Angels “took the first step”, that’s why god saved Lot from Sodom.
And gods lesson to prostitutes was to be proactive in appealing to the pious.
And Jesus was famous for saying “Whenever the least of you takes the first step, you have had the first step taken unto you by me.”
I think he said that right before he commanded the disciples to have the towns people come to them two by two.
OK? I don’t often play the “lets reverse biblical codes” game. I prefer to stay out of your demented backyard. But you people, as Christians, are being flat out pigheaded!
And Sylvie, your analogizing your student exchange trip to France to the lives of Somalian refugees make me laugh in the NOT GOOD way!
Report comment to moderator
Kevin N,
Did you read my posts? Hope so. They rise from my experiences of seeing Christians being way out in front in showing love and grace to immigrants. I see that in many campus ministries too with which I am aware.
Report comment to moderator
Lester,
I am respeoding to #33, but I added some general thoughts that are just my own.
Ronald Reagan was, in my view, the most compassionate and caring President in the history of our republic when it came to helping opprossed individuals and groups around the world. That’s why Reagan disliked communism so much. He saw it foster most of the unjust oppression and mistreatment in the world in his day.
The Reagan library once had a whole room full of accounts of vicims of conscience and oppressed individuals , families and groups. Reagan acted personally on their behalf in hundreds of cases, but he did it behind the scenes and the press paid no attention.
So it was characteristic of Reagan to help pave the way for oppressed refugees from dangerous countries to immigrate here legally.
And those friends of mine who came as refugees have made my life much better. They have made our church and our country better too.
Having served in ministry in California and Minnesota, I don’t know many people with as many opportunities as I have had to help legal immigrants and work with refugees. I have helped people become citizens and helped them adjust in many different ways.
Because I have seen immigrants with more opporession and hardship in their history than ANY of us could ever imagine, and I saw them wait in line to do it all legally, I have little use for those who cheat to get in to our country illegally.
Report comment to moderator
Sylvie,
Don’t mind Luke, you addressed that your situation is not the same as most immigrants.
Report comment to moderator
#21 MUMSEE
“RobHays, you said and I copied (I am really quite proud of myself for that!):”
(Snotty Mac computer comment follows)
Is it really that hard to copy and paste on a PC?
(Windows ‘95 like Mac ‘87, but not as good!)
Report comment to moderator
And Luke, your analogizing waiting on a nice English lady with trying to get a bunch of rebellious Somalian refugees out of burning building make me laugh in the NOT GOOD way!
Report comment to moderator
12,24,34. We all have our bigotries. I doubt we would have seen these comments if this had happened in Connecticut.
Report comment to moderator
Joel – the road to hell is paved with good intentions. Same with immigration policies. While Reagan’s policies tug at the heart strings, they’ve left our door open to anyone who can claim to be “oppressed” by their home government.
For example, I’m sure these Somalis had trouble in their former home; heck, their rudeness to authority might be a sign of mistrust, something that comes with being oppressed by your government.
However, that’s no reason to sign a blank check and let them in our country.
Report comment to moderator
Did anyone read the comments that followed the article from people who’s communities faced similar problems?
Report comment to moderator
Lester,
Real lives were saved by Reagan’s decent policies and actions on LEGAL immigration. He understood what America was. And America was often made better and more decent in the process of legal immigration.
What hurts America is ‘illegal’ immigration, not legal immigration. And there was a lot of that during Reagan’s years and I will grant that he deserves some criticism for an amnesty policy that made things worse. That was wrong-headed and time and experience have taught us that.
But those who stand in line (and I have stood in line with them, Lester) get my respect. I personally know people for whom the oppression they escaped was unthinkably horrific. I am proud that we could be a haven for them.
I have not forgotten how horrific and oppressive communism and tyranny were a generation ago. Our country is a good country and on legal terms, we were a haven for some truly oppressed people, many of whom have since lived out their gratitude to our country.
Report comment to moderator
Joel – that’s great. But many of the LEGAL immigrants have caused us problems. Look at the Somalis in this case. Many of the MS-13 gang members are legal immigrants. Remember the Mariel Boatlift? Didn’t work out too well for us.
Yes, legal immigration is good. But there are better ways to vet those immigrants other than they were “oppressed.”
FYI – our country is not the only haven for the oppressed. There are many others, but I guess they have actual working immigration laws.
Report comment to moderator
Lester wrote, “But many of the LEGAL immigrants have caused us problems.”
So have many native-born citizens.
But many immigrants who came as refugees have made great contributions too.
The key is that we need to help them assimilate and adjust and they should be willing.
I will agree with you that limits are needed. Liberia no longer has refugee status for us and I understand that policy is getting tightened across the board. You and I may not be so far apart, but in Reagan’s day, communism was wreaking havoc on millions of lives and Reagan could not just shut all the doors in the case of refugees.
What we’ve done yearly since, however, is take in millions and millions of illegals who are NOT refugees but are downright criminals and opportunists. This should be stopped and none of the presidential candiates we have now will even come close to trying.
Report comment to moderator
LMBO
Report comment to moderator
Tyson Foods has a habit of using large groups of immigrants who are culturally different than the other inhabitants. In part, this resembles a divide and conquer strategy to keep the working classes attacking each other and not the meat packing conglomerate who exploits them. The journalist played his role as mindless accessory perfectly.
As for the cultural conflicts, a little education on both sides might reveal the true nature of the complaints. Politeness is a virtue that many non-Anglo Saxons underestimated. In fact, many of my European relatives and in-laws find the whole concept absurd – where’s the honesty. Somali is a failed state in which people have relied on tribalism and handouts for decades. Vietnamese refugees in Canada originally considered Canadians as racist and rude until they realized Canadians just don’t like to talk to anyone not just the Vietnamese. Canadians consider many Americans arrogant when they are actually just enthusiastic and (overly) friendly (no Walmart greeters in Canada, nor are there morning cheer sessions even Toyota didn’t try that here) the list is endless.
Report comment to moderator
I know that part of Tennessee, and I agree that the locals are generally kind, polite and hospitable.
I hope the refugees will be won over and changed by kindness. Almost everyone who moves to TN becomes friendlier and more hospitable.
It’s going to take some very forbearing and understanding souls to cut through the morass of cultural shocks and clashes. It’s a messy, difficult business, but ultimately worthwhile.
It’s be a good idea to keep both groups and that clash in prayer.
Report comment to moderator
I’ve bought my last Tyson chicken.
Report comment to moderator
I haven’t bought Tyson chicken since I found out years ago about Tyson’s connection to Bill Clinton.
The article states the Hispanic immigrants are not arrogant and rude, they are appreciative of the assistance they receieve. Not so the Somalis.
Why is it racist if the good people of Tennnessee don’t want to put up with arrogant and rude? If a two year old behaved this way, you couldn’t tolerate it at all! But you make all these excuses. If you read the book “Infidel” written by a Somali, you would know that she says the same thing about her own people. This is how they treated the Dutch who bent over backwards for them and made excuses for them. We shouldn’t make the same PC mistake.
Report comment to moderator
back to topJoin The Conversation
You need to be a registered user of WORLDonTheWeb.com to "join the conversation."
If you are not a member yet, what are you waiting for? Register / Login Now!