Books: The Six-Book Challenge
I once knew a man who had carved out a fine career as a writer, but had never finished college. Somewhere in his 30’s, he decided to finish his education — but on his own terms. As a family man with a full time job, he could neither afford the time nor the money to return to the traditional classroom. So he turned to books. He would pick a subject — say, congressional history or energy independence — and read six books about it, taking care to choose authors with differing perspectives and worldviews.
Why six books? I have no idea, though six books would make a more thorough study of most topics than most of us pursue outside of school.
I thought it would be interesting for us to challenge each other to the six-book challenge.
So let’s do this: Pick a topic you think other WMB citizens seem…well, a little uninformed on. A little stuck in the mud. Then recommend several books that you think might broaden their education.
Since we’re not trying to replace college knowledge, we’ll make this a bit more doable with a lower minimum number of books, while keeping the six-book ceiling. You must recommend at least three books, but no more than six, on your chosen topic — which can be anything from global warming to conservative philosophy to how the Bush administration botched Iraq to evidence for intelligent design.
If you decide to take someone’s challenge and actually read the books they recommend (which can be had on the serious cheap from Amazon’s used book sellers, BTW), please say so on the thread.
This could be velly intellesting. . .




Learn it! Speak it! Live it!
Bring Christmas to a child in need!








Click to Print
Include Comments











back to top36 Comments to “Books: The Six-Book Challenge”
Three very different books on writing:
THREE USES OF THE KNIFE by David Mamet
BIRD BY BIRD by Anne Lamott
ONE WRITER’S BEGINNINGS by Eudora Welty
Report comment to moderator
On Christian History,
“Christian History in Plain Language” by Bruce Shelly from a protestant perspective.
“Christ the King- Lord of History” by Anne Carroll a very conservative Catholic perspective
“A Concise History of the Catholic Church”, By Thomas Bokenkotter, A liberal almost secular perspective.
Christian History Magazine another protestant perspective
I know the last one isn’t a book. None of these go into any depth about any one subject, but all are great overviews for a beginner.
Report comment to moderator
#2.It was while reading these books that I learned something very interesting about historians. It’s not what they put in that shows their bias, it’s what they leave out. The same could probably said of journalist.
Report comment to moderator
Concerning the threat from militant Islam, the following are important books:
i. Terrorist Hunter, Anonymous. Later outed as Rita Katz. The most important on the list.
2. Koran, Mohammed. A very difficult but essential read.
3. The Truth About Mohammed, Robert Spencer. And anything else by Spencer.
4. What Went Wrong, Bernard Lewis. (… Looking for words to describe this important book. What Islam does to a civilization.)
5. The Al Qaeda Reader, Raymond Ibrahim. The Mein Kempf of Islam. Their plans for us in their words. It should probably be listed higher.
6. Infidel, Ayaan Hirsi Ali. Islam and African culture and it’s effect on a young woman (who still has bodyguards).
I’ve reached my limit, so I won’t mention Now they Call Me Infidel, or See No Evil (This book definitely belongs in the above list of essential reading somewhere.), nor “My Year Inside Radical Islam. A liberal Jew finds Allah at a Baptist college. Was radicalized (if that’s a word) for a year. Interesting, but not a top six book.
Sorry about the cheating, but not enough to delete it.
Report comment to moderator
I committed a grave sin, worthy of death, above by saying Mohammed wrote the Koran. He wrote the Koran like Tertius (Rom. 16:22) wrote the letter to the Romans.
Report comment to moderator
If you decide to take someone’s challenge and actually read the books they recommend (which can be had on the serious cheap from Amazon’s used book sellers, BTW)
And don’t forget – you can always read the books at the bookstore for free to save even more money!
Lynn, all I ever had was a semester of Bible college, so I’m something of an autodidact myself (no, Outkast, that’s not a bad word). But this idea of reading 6 books per subjects seems excessive. I’ve found that reading 6 short articles on a subject is enough to make me an expert on any topic. I read them on the internet, of course, and I’ve always found Angelfire pages to be the most trustworthy sources of information.
Report comment to moderator
I find it interesting that eternity, spaceand a number of other constructs regarding the fundamental objective nature of the universe get raised in this blog in a variety of contexts in this blog.
Given this aspect of intertest here, I suggest the following books might prove enlightening:
Weinberg: “The First Three Minutes”
Hawkings and Penrose: “On Space and Time”
and perhaps
Barbour: “The End of Time”
One might then explore Hawkings “A Brief History of Time” for his comments on time as complex plane.
I suggest this set of books raise some interestring questions regarding:
a) what do we mean by time
b) why does time have a start? what is meant by time having an end?
c) why is there no “one time” for all parts of the universe? Why can one position in the universe have multiple time rates?
d) what does it mean when parts of the universe “disappear from this space and time”? (see schwarzfield radius)
e) why does the third law of thermodynamics exist? (it is not contained in the fundamental laws of mechanics)
f) what does it mean when we find evidence than both space and time are quantized?
among other questions.
And when one is done, one might want to consider Hawkings’s comments on time in the context of traditional wave theory: one interpretation is that all times are present at all times, just in different quantities (consider the Fourier expansion of waves).
Enjoy!
Report comment to moderator
Lynn and Night Train,
I don’t know where you live but public libraries are also useful. Illinois has a terrific interlibrary loan system (even including some university libraries) and my library card is good at almost any library in the state.
Report comment to moderator
Harrison (at #1), you neglected to tell us the topic under which those three titles fall.
Report comment to moderator
Kathy, I love interlibrary loan! ILO can usually find just about any book you can think of, no matter how obscure, or how long it’s been out of print.
Report comment to moderator
“I have always preferred the Church, but that is not smart enough for my mother. She prefers the Army, but that is a great deal too smart for me”.
This topic is way to smart for me.
Report comment to moderator
When spring come around I will need some things to read at those long days at the park. I’ve already found Harrison’s list on the interlibrary website. I will look at Chas’s list next. Musing’s seems over my head. Which would you suggest as start for a right brainer.
Report comment to moderator
Kbells,
If one wants to start light, perhaps Hawking’s “Brief History of Time” would get one started. Again, I find Hawking’s comments on time as a complex plane most interesting and enlightening. It also, however, touches on all the other topics.
The First Three Minutes is also easy reading.
“On Space and Time” requires care to read. It can be intimidating unless one is very careful in how one reads it.
Report comment to moderator
This is the most telling thing Night Train has ever written:
“I’ve found that reading 6 short articles on a subject is enough to make me an expert on any topic.”
Six short articles, Night Train? Makes you an EXPERT on ANY topic? Really?
Report comment to moderator
Kbells:
“Church History in Plain Language” was my high school church history textbook (I was homeschooled via a very very very conservative curriculum), and I found it refreshingly balanced though obviously with a Protestant bent. Still, all my previous church history had sort of dropped the Catholic church after the Reformation, and this book actually addressed things like Vatican II.
So, that’s to say, great choice and great book. I’ll look up the others you mention.
Report comment to moderator
#1 HSK:
I’d add Annie Dillard’s “The Writing Life” and Stephen King’s “On Writing” to that. Dillard’s is poetic and, well, very much her; King’s book is wonderfully down-to-earth and practical – and I don’t like his books or his market very much at all.
Report comment to moderator
This is what I do all the time. Find a subject or author and read everything. Unfortunately, one of my most recent subjects: the Rwandan genocide.
We Wish to Inform You That Tomorrow We Will be Killed With Our Families: Stories from Rwanda by Philip Gourevitch The stories are unrelentingly horrifying and filled with “the idiocy, the waste, the sheer wrongness” of one group of Rwandans (Hutus) methodically exterminating another (Tutsis).
A People Betrayed: The Role of the West in Rwanda’s Genocide
by Linda Melvern. After I finished this book, I hated the UN and had nothing but contempt for France.
An Ordinary Man : An Autobiography by Paul Rusesabagina and Tom Zoellner. A fine book upon which the excellent movie Hotel Rwanda was based. Rusesabagina was just as confused by it all as the rest of us, but rose above his confusion to do a marvelous work.
Over a Thousand Hills I Walk With You by Hanna Jansen and Elizabeth D. Crawford A young adult book, tells the story through the eyes of a much loved Catholic child, the only survivor of her family, who was adopted by a German couple.
Left to Tell: Discovering God Amidst the Rwandan Holocaust by Immaculee Ilibagiza
Someone on this blog recommended this book; it was interesting first person account that at least tried to figure out why in the spiritual context.
Machete Season: The Killers in Rwanda Speak by Jean Hatzfeld Interviews with the killers; I read this one trying to understand what would cause a neighbor to turn on someone they knew well and slaughter them with a machete. of course, there is no answer.
Shake Hands with the Devil : The Failure of Humanity in Rwanda by Romo Dallaire
As former head of the late 1993 U.N. peacekeeping mission in Rwanda, this general was broken by the end. Very frustrating, very political, and heartbreaking.
Report comment to moderator
Alissa beware “Christ the King- Lord of History” by Anne Carroll is very bias. I suggested it as a look Christian history from a Pre-Vactican II Catholic presective.
Report comment to moderator
Art & the church:
- Modern Art & the Death of Culture, Hans Rookmaaker
- Imagine: A Vision for Christians in the Arts, Steve Turner
- Mystery & Manners: Occasional Prose, Flannery O’Connor
- A Profound Weakness: Christians & Kitsch, Betty Spackman
And Image Journal, to me, is essential reading, but not a book.
Report comment to moderator
Kbells:
Thanks, good to know. I just finished a ton of reading on Marxism and aesthetics for class, so I’m in full critical reading mode right now anyhow.
Report comment to moderator
For new ways to think about Christianity:
An Arrow Pointing to Heaven (about the late and missed Rich Mullins) by James Bryan Smith
Jesus for the Nonreligious by John Shelby Spong
Stealing Jesus by Bruce Bawer.
Report comment to moderator
Lynn and Night Train,
I don’t know where you live but public libraries are also useful. Illinois has a terrific interlibrary loan system (even including some university libraries) and my library card is good at almost any library in the state.
Isn’t it weird that I didn’t think of the library? Probably because the nearest decent library to me is downtown and a pain to get to (parking is awful.) Thanks for reminding me about interlibrary loans!
Report comment to moderator
I got See No Evil by Robert Baer from the library. I would like to have a copy I could mark, but have too much else for now.
Report comment to moderator
Musing — an other good starting point is Paul Davies’ On Time or Brain Greene, the Fabric of the Cosmos.
Michelle — Barbara Coloroso who normally writes education books dealing with behaviour and bullying wrote an excellent book The Extra Ordinary Evil: A History of Genocide which is now available in paperback. It centers on the Rwandan genocide.
Report comment to moderator
Just read every National Geographic and every Scientific American published since you were born, along with the Bible, Koran and the Book of Mormon. That should take long enough and be good enough not to even have to go to school after grade school.
Still, none of it will make you successful or skillful at anything worthwhile.
Report comment to moderator
Thanks for the tip, HRW. Colorso’s book is not available through my library or local inter-library loan, but I’ll look into it when I visit the library next.
A friend taught a course at Manhattanville College (in NY) fall semester on Genocide. She and I spent a lovely Connecticut afternoon last summer discussing that grim subject and she wanted my list for her bibliography–which is why I could produce it so readily.
I appreciate Lynn’s comment about reading both sides for a full “education.” I’ve no idea how books on abortion I’ve read over the years, but I make it a point to read the pro-choice side when I see it–because it helps me minister better when I can understand where the women are coming from.
Which is also why this blog has been important–to hear both sides of a subject.
Report comment to moderator
llama post 25,
what an interesting commentary on your attitude towards learning. A great deal becomes clear now.
Report comment to moderator
In the area of philosophy, I recommend anything written by Bill Watterson. I’m so enamored by his writing that I have his complete works, in both hard cover, paperback, and the anthology.
Report comment to moderator
Anlir:
I totally agree. We had the hardcovers on our wedding registry (nobody seemed to want to give them to us, though).
Report comment to moderator
I also agree on Watterson. He is able to present two distictive philosophies, and does them both justice.
Report comment to moderator
Serious question.
When you mention Bill Watterson, are you talking about the Calvin & Hobbs Watterson, or someone else?
BTW. I mentioned See No Evil as a book about Islam. It is not about Islam, so I shouldn’t have added it there. It is by Robert Baer who was a CIA operative in the WhateverStan area of central Asia during the 1990’s. He tells part of the reason we are where we are today.
Report comment to moderator
“When you mention Bill Watterson, are you talking about the Calvin & Hobbs Watterson, or someone else?”
There is no other Bill Watterson.
Report comment to moderator
Reading six in depth books on a given subject sounds like a very good plan. But I’m dismayed at the prospect since I can hardly get through one in depth book on a subject…
That being said, I’d recommend any book on the resurrection of Jesus by William Lane Craig. The Amazon.com “for serious cheap” short version is The Son Rises. But if you’re a real scholar (read Greek) you can get his definitive work; Assessing the New Testament Evidence for the Historicity of the Resurrection of Jesus (Studies in the Bible and Early Christianity) on Amazon for $129.00.
Report comment to moderator
We don’t have Calvin & Hobbs in the local paper. I used to enjoy reading it. The tiger was always smarter than Calvin, but I always had hope for Calvin. Calvin never grows up, but you know the insight Hobbs gives him will cause him to grow into a fine man someday.
Report comment to moderator
It was a very sad day when Watterson announced that Calving and Hobbes would be ending.
Report comment to moderator
ALISSA,
Oh, yes, I’d add Dillard’s and King’s book to any good list of books on writing. And O’Connor’s MYSTERY AND MANNERS can also go on that list. I’d bet our libraries are similar.
Report comment to moderator
back to topJoin The Conversation
You need to be a registered user of WORLDonTheWeb.com to "join the conversation."
If you are not a member yet, what are you waiting for? Register / Login Now!