At the corner of gladness and need
I’ve been thinking lately about vocation, and wondering why I told myself I could become a writer. A writer is, of course, someone who writes, and so when someone like me says: “I want to be a writer,” what he means is that he wants to make a living from his writing. More than that, he probably means that he wants to make a considerable amount of money, and receive widespread accolades, all while creating what he believes constitutes true art. But for shorthand he says: “I want to be a writer.”
One of the surest ways to determine if someone who wants to be a writer can, in fact, become a writer is to examine his output. I know more than a few people who want to be writers, but not so much that they actually write. They think about writing, and talk about it, and perhaps take classes, and occasionally begin a short story, or tap out a blog post. They devote more mental energy to the thought of being writers than to mastering the craft of writing.
But among aspiring writers who actually devote themselves to honing their craft, there is still the distinction between those who make a living at it, and those who do not. This is only tangentially related to talent; Flannery O’Connor noted that if “people can learn to write badly enough, they can make a great deal of money.” It is connected, however, to one’s ability to write in a manner that will attract a paying audience, be they high, low, or middle-brow. Add to this the necessity of attracting a publisher with some marketing muscle, and competing for the decreasing sliver of mental energy devoted to reading, and the would-be writer is by no means assured that his words will ever pay even the interest on his bills.
Why, I have thought more than once, did I think I could make a go at this? It’s a purely selfish question, because I have a job. Insofar as I get paid to write, it’s on freelance gigs. So most days I have more words to set down than minutes to sort them out into paragraphs and scenes and chapters. In my reflective moments I sometimes brood over this reality, and wonder whether I haven’t let a hobby get too big for its britches. So I can turn a phrase every once in a while. Who am I to be a writer?
Perhaps you’ve had a similar period of self-doubt. Maybe you have some skill and passion that you want to pursue, but don’t know if it’s a pipe dream. It was with this in mind that I read the account in Exodus of the building of the tabernacle: “and in the hearts of all who are skillful I have put skill, that they may make all that I have commanded you.” Other translations read: “in the hearts of all who are wise-hearted I have put wisdom.”
What struck me is that God not only gives us skill, He gives us passion. He gives us the desires of our heart. The difficulty is in discerning the difference between our selfishness and His purpose, but these verses tell me not to discount passion. I write because I can’t help it. I write because sometimes, in the midst of it, I feel like I am doing what I was crafted to do. That verse from Exodus, which I’d never noticed before, helps me make sense of that feeling.
The writer by whom I’ve been most inspired, Frederick Buechner, says: “The vocation for you is the one in which your deep gladness and the world’s deep need meet.” At the very least, I’ve got the first half covered. And most days, that’s enough.














Click to Print
Include Comments











back to top14 Comments to “At the corner of gladness and need”
I can’t count the number of times I have argued “am I a writer or not?” And every time I throw down the towel and say “I quit and I’m going to get my PhD instead,” the Lord encourages me in some small way. Every single time.
I work for a literary agent who often says, “not every book that needs to be written needs to be published.” I take heart from that–because no one except my distant relatives wants to read my massive genealogy (Pioneer Stock, you can find it in the Library of Congress), or the stories of our trips. As it should be. The 25 page “story of your life,” I wrote my son for his birthday two weeks ago, also was important to write but should not be published.
So, it’s important for writers to figure out what they’re looking for when they write: publication, notoriety, or satisfaction with your work. Money really should not figure into it on the Christian novel writing side.
Some days that works for me. Other days, I wonder why I bother.
Ah, but I love the joy of creating a story and telling it well. And that’s why I’ll be back at it this afternoon.
The other thing, though, is that sometimes God calls us to do things that make no sense–but which He uses for his glory. Because I wrote a novel all last summer, I was on the computer. Since I listen to KING-FM while I write, the Internet was up. And because I appeared on several people’s IM screens, I was able to minister to them in their times of need. I’m also available to take the PCC hotline, “because I’m just home writing, anyway.”
When I look at my life, I’m forced to wonder if my urge to write is one God put in me so that I would be in the right place to minister to others in their times of need. That certainly redeemed the 88,000 word novel that just didn’t seem to work by the end of the summer. I may not like what I produced, but the fruit of the spirit definitely turned up.
Report comment to moderator
Not to disagree – as I have had similar thoughts about my free-lance writing (with a big emphasis on “free”).
But, then I think of how work is distributed in other cultures and in time past. In most of history and civilization, you worked at the shop twelve hours a day and that is just what you did. You were just happy to get work and support your family whether it was farming, drilling holes or raising cattle.
In must cultures, you took the occupation of your father and passed it along to your sons. For a baker to ask “what do I want to be when I grow up” was irrelevant.
In fact, this idea of “job choice” seems to be a rather later, Western idea as I see it.
Does God really care about my passion and job fulfillment? Or are we imposing a value that is true only in a small snippet of world history onto our idea of God?
While we have many more choices today in the US, I think many folks are still going to have to settle on jobs they don’t really have a passion for just because they have to make a living.
Report comment to moderator
How do we come to understand the world’s need?
Report comment to moderator
I loved this. Helped me slog through some of the 900-plus unread items in my Google reader this morning. Even “published” writers get burned out.
I like the Buechner quote but I wonder if we should add our gifts and talents to the equation. Ideally our passions will match our gifts, but sometimes we have a deep passion without the talent to make it happen, or we have the talent and lack the passion to use it well. I think part of fulfilling our calling might be cultivating deep passions that match our gifts.
Report comment to moderator
“I write because I can’t help it. I write because sometimes, in the midst of it, I feel like I am doing what I was crafted to do.”
There. That’s the thing I was looking for. In this you have an answer that resonates deeply with me.
I used to agonize through the very things you describe – only in reference to being an artist. I decided once in college to take my painting seriously – of a sudden it became work. Something I had always enjoyed became drudgery and I slogged through it. I didn’t do it much after that.
Now later in life, I have relaxed, since the kids are near grown, and I’ve slaved many a year doing what I disliked anyway… (I was an auto-mechanic in a former life.
)
I now feel this same way any time I make something – it doesn’t matter if it’s watercolor, or cabinet work, or a jig to use in the shop, developing some programming, or even… an artistic turning – I’m making stuff because I can’t help it. I’ve got to make something or explode… I feel the God has made me for this purpose, and when I’m not doing it, I feel I’ve wasted what he’s given me.
I resolved one of my worst anxieties about making things because I finally realized it’s not within me to stick to one medium forever and ever, amen. I realized that I need a wide variety of things to keep my mind occupied. Simply becoming a watercolor artist didn’t satisfy my need for the technical/mechanical/spatial part of my nature. Since accepting this, my anxiety level dropped significantly…
And making things isn’t drudgery….
Report comment to moderator
To add to Alisa: Especially published writers get burned out.
And yes – I think I’m finding my vocation by noting where God has gifted me, and where He hasn’t. I spent the last year agonizing over the fact that I can’t write fiction to save my life (truly). And then I realized that all that means is that if God wants me to write a novel, he’ll just have to give that novel to me in His grace, and what I need to do is be ready to write it down (and I’ll definitely know that it’s not due to my brilliance). And in the meantime, I just keep writing.
Report comment to moderator
I appreciated this article and conversation. I know the verse you’re talking about, and it’s inspired me since high school.
As long as you all keep writing well, I’ll keep reading.
Report comment to moderator
Ok…I have a deep need for your work Tony. Now you’re complete. Now what the heck am I supposed to do.
Good stuff, Sir. Keep up the terrific writing.
Report comment to moderator
I really enjoy reading, so in that sense all you writers are filling a need!
I’ve been told often that I express myself well and “should write”, but it is definitely not a passion for me, except when I have something specific to express which I have a “passion” for. So it’s settled–I’m not a writer.
Good stuff, Tony!
Report comment to moderator
Michelle, I’ve wondered the same thing, if my perceived calling to write has nothing to do with widespread publication. I confess I don’t like that thought very much, which is a sign I still need humbling in that area.
Outdeep,
I believe God, having created us in his image, has crafted us so that we are most fulfilled when engaged in some aspect of creation ourselves. For some that would be art, for others the creation of a loving home for their children, for others, some kind of healing, for others, growing food, and so on. I believe when we are not engaged in some aspect of creation, we are prone to malaise and sloth. That would suggest that God does care whether we are passionate about what we do. I see it as wrapped up in what Os Guinness describes as the artificial distinction between the sacred and the secular — the notion that there are “God things,” which involve Bible reading and church attendance (or “full-time ministry,” if one is a pastor or missionary), and then “world things,” which are the rest of the necessities of our existence, and which we imagine God is largely indifferent to, compared to the “God things.” The Bible says, however, that he directs the paths of those who acknowledge him in all their ways, and that he gives them the desires of their hearts, and that he has prepared their good works beforehand, all of which imply that God cares about the entirety of our activities.
Reg,
I don’t know if we can understand the world’s need, but perhaps just the needs in our little corners of it, though I find often that there have been needs all along, to which I have been blind.
Alisa,
You are right on with gifts being in there. Someone once said: “Anything worth doing is worth doing poorly,” and there’s something to that, but it’s probably safe to assume that for most of us, the paths we are to walk have something to do with our God-given strengths. On the other hand, the Lord called Moses to lead his people out of bondage, even though Moses was a terrible public speaker.
Report comment to moderator
Theologically I would agree with you. God probably does care about our passions. Nevertheless, the vast majority of people through out history work to make a living. Relatively few have the luxury to work to fulfill their passion. Of all those with a passion to write, maybe 5% get to make a living at it. The rest have to make ends meet by getting a job at Wal-Mart or wherever their their training or job experiences leads them. This was even truer in times past when vocational choice was not even an option. (”No Father, I will not tend the sheep – I want to be a writer”. Ha!)
I would love to work in an area I was passionate about. The truth is, in my situation I have to fulfill my passion on my own time in volunteer work because passion does not always translate into jobs that pay the bills. In fact, for most people, it does not.
So, one should follow their passion, trust God that He might open doors of sorts, but I wouldn’t dangle the carrot too much. Sometimes you just have to work to make a living.
Report comment to moderator
Tony – But then God gave Moses the help of Aaron as his “mouthpiece”, which demonstrates how God often brings others alongside us to fill in our gaps.
In a way, we’re all to fill in the gaps of each other.
Report comment to moderator
Outdeep,
Agreed. Sometimes we are fortunate to have a job doing something we are passionate about which also pays the bills. Many people don’t have that luxury. They work the job to pay the bills and pursue their passion in other ways. Occasionally, this independent indulgence of their passion leads to a different job where their passion and talents lie, but often not.
Report comment to moderator
I think there is a flip side to pursuing one’s passion. Namely, do we suffer more to attain the dream job than we would if we just “got a real job”?
Looking back on my career so far, I wonder if I would have had the resilience to get through the stress, the unrealistic demands and the poor pay if I hadn’t been so vigorously in pursuit of “the dream”. Would I have suffered such poor conditions if they had occured in a “bread and butter” job? I can’t be certain, but I doubt that I would have.
Report comment to moderator
back to topJoin The Conversation
You need to be a registered user of WORLDonTheWeb.com to "join the conversation."
If you are not a member yet, what are you waiting for? Register / Login Now!