The sick joke is on her
My post of yesterday, “Abortion as Art” started off with the caveat: This is not a joke, where Yale art student Aliza Shvarts impregnated herself and aborted fetuses for an art project. Apparently, though, it was a joke. Or at least a “creative fiction.” The Yale Office of Public Affairs posts this announcement:
Ms. Shvarts is engaged in performance art. Her art project includes visual representations, a press release and other narrative materials. She stated to three senior Yale University officials today, including two deans, that she did not impregnate herself and that she did not induce any miscarriages. The entire project is an art piece, a creative fiction designed to draw attention to the ambiguity surrounding form and function of a woman’s body.
She is an artist and has the right to express herself through performance art.
Had these acts been real, they would have violated basic ethical standards and raised serious mental and physical health concerns.
Thanks, Yale. Does lying also violate basic ethical standards, too? Oh, I don’t know. The whole thing still testifies to the dereliction of universities and contemporary art into the realm of the absurd.




Learn it! Speak it! Live it!
Bring Christmas to a child in need!








Click to Print
Include Comments











back to top21 Comments to “The sick joke is on her”
According to the Abortion Stirs Outrage thread, and this article, she still maintains it’s not fiction.
Report comment to moderator
Do we REALLY need a third thread on which to discuss this shameful episode? Are not two sufficient?
Report comment to moderator
Even if she did just “think it up,” only a sick, disturbed mind could conceive of this. She does have some sort of project to show based on this scenario, and for a school to approve a project like that is appalling.
Report comment to moderator
I’m with Klasko. I think the best thing we can do for this girl is ignore her.
Report comment to moderator
Well Harrison, at least you didn’t get Rick-rolled!
Report comment to moderator
Yes, we can use another thread on this topic, as the story is developing. For one thing we learn from the Yale News that:
Pia Lindman, Shvarts’s thesis adviser, and Davenport College Dean Craig Harwood could not be reached for comment Thursday. Art Director of Undergraduate Studies Henk van Assen deferred comment to the Yale Office of Public Affairs.
Even the liberal authorities at Yale are running for cover. The world needs to know the depths to which this foolish “university” has descended.
Of course, we ordinary bitter folks are forsaking the wonders of the avant garde and merely clinging to quaint religious notions.
Report comment to moderator
Is it any wonder art in public schools loses funding when the university colleges of art produce such students?
Report comment to moderator
Pity and prayer — two things she needs.
(Klasko, since we have three threads, am I out of place for posting two links to my own blog post?
BTW, I agree with the sentiment conveyed in your post above.)
Report comment to moderator
Someone will have to answer. Sadly, it will probably not be the girl but the person who described artificial insemination and abortion as acts that “violated basic ethical standards.”
Report comment to moderator
Is anyone at all shocked that extreme, left wing, if artful socialists actually think, or don’t think, this way?
A good round of electroshock treatments should fix her up just like it would all of her ilk.
Report comment to moderator
No harm, no foul. Score still tied. Play on.
Report comment to moderator
I won’t say anything. I won’t.
Yes I will – I.T.Y.S.
bad Amph, bad bad
Seriously, though – the story had issues that were obvious to the critical eye, although I didn’t notice it either at first. This should serve as a reminder for us to not believe everything we read, no matter how much we want (or don’t want) it to be true.
Report comment to moderator
Performance artist – am I good, or what?
bad. bad bad.
Report comment to moderator
Yes, Amph … you’re good. We appreciate the sanity.
Report comment to moderator
I appreciate you drawing our attention to this yesterday, Amph.
ITYS? How about ATUS (Amph Told Us So)?!?
Report comment to moderator
I want to know what is going on at Yale. We have a right to know what is being allowed, and taught within the walls of all the Universities, and that would include Yale.
Maybe this story is just the ‘tip’ of the problem.
Report comment to moderator
16 – “I want to know what is going on at Yale.”
This is going on in colleges all over the nation in the name of “art,” Victoria. I am not necessarily talking about the hoax abortion aspect but the heavy-handed angst, absurdity and anger in those who presume themselves to be artists but don’t have the talent or the grace to pull off anything except shocking messes and/or tantrums and call it “performance art.”
All this has nothing whatsoever to do with actual art, but that’s the name they give it. They want their audience to either be outraged or to praise them. What they don’t want is for us to think for ourselves and refuse to consider it art.
There is such a thing as aesthetic intelligence, and a lot more of it comes from regular Joe’s than it does from academics and intellectuals.
Report comment to moderator
Joel,
Please, you don’t need to give me a ‘overview’ regarding the world of art. I studied art for a period of time, I’m not a novice….I don’t believe anyone on this blog is either, even if they never studied art.
I know that these things go on in colleges across the US, its common knowledge. I am talking about ‘extreme’ situations such as the one at Yale, this isn’t the norm.
Report comment to moderator
18 – Cool. Just an open-ended reply. Take care.
Report comment to moderator
Not so fast.
The young woman is still claiming that the story is true. :0
http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,351730,00.html
Report comment to moderator
I am reminded that in 10th grade history I wanted to write my research paper on the Catholic Church (remember I attended an Independent Methodist Church School, who thought the Pope would eventually be the AntiChrist) my teacher Miss Emily Garner suggested I do my report on the Greek Orthodox Church instead. What a reasonable woman. Someone should have done the same for this young woman.
Report comment to moderator
back to topJoin The Conversation
You need to be a registered user of WORLDonTheWeb.com to "join the conversation."
If you are not a member yet, what are you waiting for? Register / Login Now!