The search for depravity
The search for depravity around the world is a particularly western fascination, it seems. Frank Furedi at sp!ked says that the media loves to point out some failed society somewhere and how horribly its people are suffering. Think Darfur. Think Myanmar. Think China.
Recently, I have found it difficult to take seriously Western media coverage of events overseas. Often, the coverage is driven by a mean-spirited desire to discover that ‘they’, too, have problems – and that many of them are far worse than ours. There seems to be an urge to deliver shallow sermons about the failures of morally inferior communities, and an impulse to gloat over their troubles. Within minutes of receiving news about the terrible earthquake in China this week, we were told about the shoddy structures built by corrupt contractors, who were so concerned with taking advantage of the country’s economic miracle that they didn’t bother to make anything earthquake-proof.
Events that occur far away give the media a licence to live out its fantasies, and allow it to tell cautionary tales about dark places over there. Until recently, the media obsession with the pornography of suffering was confined to Africa, and to a handful of ‘failed’ societies. In the US, Darfur has become the cause célèbre of an entertainment industry in search of a crusade. Across the Atlantic, here in Britain, Zimbabwe has emerged as the ideal place for a twenty-first century replay of the Heart of Darkness. Only this time Kurtz – the white ivory trader-cum-demigod in Conrad’s novel – has a microphone in his hand as he tells TV viewers that ‘something must be done’.
This is an ironic about-face for the liberal elite, who are the first to decry some terrible situation in another country. For a long time, they talked about how other, poorer nations were morally superior to the West and how our oppressive Eurocentric ideas only made these other cultures seem depraved. Now, the liberal elite seems to be doing just the opposite, calling these other cultures, or at least their leadership, depraved. Sounds awfully conservative to me. Read on about how news of international devastation is a kind of “News Porn.”




Learn it! Speak it! Live it!
Special Student Discount for WORLD!








Click to Print
Include Comments










back to top7 Comments to “The search for depravity”
Conservatives like to see the news as an illustration of personal moral depravity and the fitness of the template provided by orthodox theology. Harrison especially likes to see liberals and secularists reach for conservative explanations for troubling phenomenon.
Harrison offers the Spiked article as evidence that liberals have betrayed their principles by borrowing the language of God to account for reality. Sorry to spoil his fun, but I don’t think it does. this. The member of the “liberal elite” who wrote the article clearly is furious at journalists who pull Calvinism out of wikipedia to write the news. Harrison seems to assume that because journalists belong to the “liberal elite,” the organizing concepts of their stories have something to do with liberalism, but the conclusion doesn’t follow. I think the depravity journalism is a function of supply and demand.
Since conservatives make up the bulk of the market for mass media, it’s not surprising that journalism supplies the demand. Fox News didn’t spring from the brain of Roger Ailes. The article in Spiked criticizes journalists for pandering to conservatives, it doesn’t betray the secularist theory of the good and the bad.
Report comment to moderator
Nah, I think the liberals are starting to realize just how depraved they’ve become and they need to find people who they can label as worse so they can feel better about themselves.
Report comment to moderator
There is nothing more righteous in the world than a breathless liberal media anchor commenting on a natural disaster and the evil of governmental response whether to Katrina, Myanmar, or Szechuan. They exult at the sordid images of disasters and the inevitably feeble responses of men and women to ameliorate them.
It never occurs to these poor characters that they and their precious networks in behaving as ratings vultures are themselves richly involved in evil.
Report comment to moderator
NJLAWY-ERR (keeping with the fashion of modifying the spelling of people’s tags in order to hold up a mirror to them, and to be a scold, i.e. SCROOP MOUTH, which I love, and ANLIAR, which is lame)
Since liberals are depraved, they can’t know it. Someone on an adjacent thread just played Romans 1 — “God has given them up to their own depraved way of thinking . . . they not only do these things themselves but approve such conduct in others.” As the apostle says in that immortal passage, all liberal thinking has ended in futility. It’s over. Their misguided minds are plunged in darkness. Depravity puts liberals beyond remorse.
You’d have to admit, NJ, that a liberal would make an unsuccessful depravity monger, ignorantly missing the evil under his nose and getting scooped by WorldMag.
In the face of terrible things, the liberal elitist whom Harrison presents for our consideration is blaming journalists of all people. You’d think Harrison would be attacking him for shooting the messengers, but I think Harrison’s confused. My point is that reporters who search out the key to human experience in a religious explanation like depravity are submitting to market discipline. They owe it to their careers and families.
If I were a journalist, my self respect would urge me to tell people the truth that suffering is due to neglect of liberal remedies. But when the customers prefer the taste of Calvinism and are reassured by the just deserts of others, I’m afraid I’d have to go ahead and tell them that all the world needs is a Savior.
Report comment to moderator
This post proves yet again that HSK can think only in terms of crude stereotypes.
Report comment to moderator
Scroopy, I was fooling with ya. That’s what the “nah” meant, and you fell for it.
Ah, liberals……
Peter Leavitt’s post was far more serious, and I join it.
Report comment to moderator
I’m not really buying the premise that the liberal media is on a ‘crusade’ hell-bent on finding people worse off than us.
The liberal media is simply on a crusade to promote liberalism which in modern society is defined as social re-engineering through the strong arm of government.
Pointing out government failure is a sweet spot for them, whether foreign or domestic, because every problem in the world is solved by fixing government. Listen to NPR or BBC. Every story is about something government is or isn’t doing.
On the commercial side, news is marketing. Advertisers want people and people want entertainment, tragedy, sex and violence.
I also disagree that “Journalists’ hunger for the images, sounds and smells of horror shows the extent to which they’ve abandoned their responsibility to analyse and make sense of events.”
The last thing I want is some pretty boy talking head to try to make sense of the events. Heaven help us!
Report comment to moderator
back to topJoin The Conversation
You need to be a registered user of WORLDonTheWeb.com to "join the conversation."
If you are not a member yet, what are you waiting for? Register / Login Now!