Losing children
I recently reviewed Hara Estroff Marano’s book, A Nation of Wimps, for The Wall Street Journal. In it, Marano argues that much of the self-destruction we see among teens and twenty-somethings can be attributed to “overparenting,” an obsessive desire to insulate children from negative consequences. The perverse result, Marano says, is that children end up brittle and burdened with anxiety and fear.
There’s something to be said for that argument, but as I read the book, I found myself wondering whether a decline in substantive faith might also have something to do with statistics on teen and twenty-something drinking and drug use, suicide, depression, and hyper-sexualization. I read somewhere that the average American man spends more time watching television than talking, in a meaningful way, to his own children. And more and more, a father isn’t even in the home. When we kick these two supports out from under a child — meaningful relationships with God and father — perhaps we shouldn’t be surprised that guidance counselors and after-school programs can’t close the frightfully dark gap.
It’s a gap that looms in the hearts of too many children, and it rends our social fabric as well. We are increasingly two nations, and the significant divide isn’t one of race, or income, but something more essential and less remediable: the heart. We have dwelling among us, on every street, in every school and workplace, a nation of the broken-hearted, of young people who don’t really know, in the deepest part of themselves, that they are loved by a father in heaven or on the earth.
And who is going to set it to rights? Presidential candidates? Public schools? Writers like Marano, who dare not mention the word faith?
How are we going to reach these young people, and stop the next generation of them from being similarly wounded? I wonder what would happen if every church in America took a day to pray, and plan, and then act to close this gap. Some probably wouldn’t change much at all, because they are already devoting significant resources and time to this fight. Others would likely need to transform themselves. But this is the fight, I think — not gas prices or federal tax rates or any of the other things politicians find it easier to talk about than the reality that we are increasingly betraying our own children.




Learn it! Speak it! Live it!
Bring Christmas to a child in need!








Click to Print
Include Comments











back to top5 Comments to “Losing children”
I am no expert on parenting and it does seem to me that there are multiple causes to this problem. I have seen over-strict parents lose their kids as well as the over-permissive.
One of the few things I ended up doing right in parenting is to make it clear and demonstrate that they have to work out the consequences of their own choices. While some parents over-managed their kid’s high school career and produced children who could memorize their way through a test and had a Christianity that was shallow cliches and bumper-stickers.
I made it clear that if they didn’t do well on a test or missed assignments, it was their problem. Have fun in detention if they are late. As a result I saw my kids take ownership of their life and approach jobs with a kind of seriousness and responsibility that got them noticed and promoted quickly.
Not bragging here as I did more things wrong than I did right. But, in retrospect, I do see value in not micro-managing my kids or living my goals through them but giving advise and allowing them the freedom to find their own way.
Report comment to moderator
Kids need the right balance between independence and help/guidance/rules. And that’s a difficult balance to find, and isn’t in the same place for everyone. So far I think I’m not erring too far in one direction or the other, as our boys seem to be doing well at taking increasing responsibility as they get older.
My own parents wanted to give us “freedom to find our own way” as Outdeep speaks of, but – in my opinion – left us too much on our own. We didn’t get in trouble, we happened to be the kind of kids who preferred to follow the rules. But it’s been hard for both my sister and me to learn to make decisions confidently, even though we had so many opportunities to do so as children, because we also didn’t have any guidance in how to do it.
Our mother had had no opportunity to make her own choices as a child, or to take on responsibilities. She wanted to make sure we did. I don’t remember a single time my parents ever asked if my schoolwork was done, or even to see my report card. Whether I cleaned my room was my own business. What we chose to believe about God was up to us. We could learn how to cook by trial and error, just as she did.
So I had plenty of independence and responsibility from a young age, but it terrified me. The idea of growing up and being on my own – how would I ever figure it out? My mother still wanted someone to take care of her and make her decisions for her, long after I did grow up. And she marvelled that somehow my sister and I had more or less figured it out, in spite of her inability to guide us.
So I try to strike a balance. Let them try things, but don’t make them do stuff on their own that they’re not ready for. A nudge or a push is needed sometimes, to get them to try something new and a little scary. But I’m there to help when they need it, not standing back hands-off to leave them to sink or swim.
Report comment to moderator
Independence is great, but if too little rein is given, the pendulum swings the other way: parents constantly encouraging “initiative” and wondering why their child (even their older, living-at-home-during-the-summer college students) doesn’t grow up and take responsibility.
And all the time they’re telling them when to clean the bathroom and wash the dishes and not leaving them any room to actually grow up and impress the parents.
Report comment to moderator
Good insights, Tony. Good post. Rather than opine, I will chew on it.
Report comment to moderator
Pauline, I think much of parenting is our correcting the over-emphasis of our parents. To me, giving my kids responsibility was important in reaction to my mother’s micro-managing when I grew up. It seems your correction was the opposite. That balance is difficult which is why it is important to think about.
Report comment to moderator
back to topJoin The Conversation
You need to be a registered user of WORLDonTheWeb.com to "join the conversation."
If you are not a member yet, what are you waiting for? Register / Login Now!