Commencement watch: White elephant at Morehouse
Morehouse College, one of the most prominent “black” colleges in the United States, has just had something unusual happen. Or at least it seems unusual. They’ve just had their first white valedictorian. His name is Joshua Packwood. Some blacks are mad about it.
In some ways, the defensive pose is understandable. Black consciousness is rooted in the need for oppositional ideologies, developed to protect the community from the ignominy and violence resulting from racism. The Harlem Renaissance, negritude, the Black Arts and Black Power movements all sought to affirm the value of black and African culture, heritage and identity. In his essay “Orphée Noir,” the French philosopher Jean-Paul Sartre identified negritude as a sort of “anti-racist racism.”




Learn it! Speak it! Live it!
Bring Christmas to a child in need!








Click to Print
Include Comments











back to top37 Comments to “Commencement watch: White elephant at Morehouse”
Hmmm. Now wouldn’t we all be applauding if a black valedictorian crossed the stage in a predominately, historically WHITE college? Oh wait, none of those exist any longer…
Report comment to moderator
Black consciousness developed to protect the community from violence resulting from racism?
You cannot be serious.
Violence from racism is almost completely one -sided. In fact the most taboo subject (arguably) in America today is black-on-white violence.
It is almost an undeclared war on white people.
Report comment to moderator
This is too ironic. Democrat voters in our nation just appointed its first-ever black Presidential candidate, and yet people scream when the first-ever white valedictorian at a college is selected? Hmm . . .
Report comment to moderator
‘Instead of worrying about Josh Packwood, we should concern ourselves with making blackness a positive force in a pluralistic and globalized world.’
Yes, that would be a good idea since blacks are not all black and color is not an end in itself.
But, blacks have a hard time keeping their racists in check as much as whites do. Maybe someone will provide an example of white racism. OOOPPPSSS too late.
Report comment to moderator
Well it would be nice if we had an argument or editorial written by someone who actually was upset by Packwood’s success. That way Llama, Outcast, Nick, and Kin wouldn’t have to pretend like they understand their feelings or their motivations.
In this format all we have is The Root rebutting a phantom.
Granted The Root’s position sounds correct. For thems that actually read it!!!
Post-modern pluralism will inevitably that these little ideological scrapes happen. Those upset by Packwood’s accomplishment need to act a little less conservative.
Report comment to moderator
Luke,
I try to keep emotions and feelings, and the understanding of them, far away from my motivations.
Report comment to moderator
I always thought the Valedictorian was chosen based on who had the highest GPA? Skin pigment should be irrelevant no? What would MLK say??
Report comment to moderator
I’m confused.
Morehouse is a black college? Where is the diversity, where is the multiculturalism?
I think Morehouse should reach out and try and attract more non-black students.
If the non-blacks students can’t afford tuition? Offer them scholarships.
If the non-blacks students grades aren’t good enough? Offer affirmative action.
If the non-blacks students feel out of place? Offer European studies taught only by Europeans.
If the non-black students still feel out of place? Offer them non-blacks only dorms and allow the students to form European-American organizations that specifically exclude blacks. Of course no blacks’ only organizations would be allowed.
And if blacks think this is unfair call them racists.
Report comment to moderator
Nick Peters #2
“People are entitled to their own opinions,’ observed Daniel Moynihan, “not their own facts.”
The era of the Harlem Renaissance was an ugly time when the Klan was widespread and violence and lynchings vicitimized many African Americans.
The present climate of relations between the races is far more congenial, with the majority of the violence being black on black. Nowhere is there systematic and organized black on white violence equivalent to its earlier opposite.
The present model of race is inadequate and contrafactual. There is one race, the human race, or a vast spectrum of skin tone, hair texture, and ethnicity, assorted into dozens of fluid races. The only way out of the morass is straight ahead, where the blackness of presidential candidates and the whiteness of valedictorians are ignored for the irrelevancies they are.
Report comment to moderator
#9 – “The present model of race is inadequate and contrafactual. There is one race, the human race, or a vast spectrum of skin tone, hair texture, and ethnicity, assorted into dozens of fluid races.”
And yet the media is all atwitter with the “black-ness” of Obama.
Wouldn’t one think that highlights a visible difference? Wouldn’t one think that fosters a perpetuation of division?
Report comment to moderator
I saw several interviews with Packwood. He is a brilliant and quite charming guy who I suspect will go a long way in the world. He had the guts to take four years of his life and explore what amounts to a parallel universe and did very well at it. Bravo for him.
And brickbats to the bloggers who had to go a long way to find a couple of discontented black naysayers. That’s well beneath their usual standards.
Report comment to moderator
And they say racism is dead ….
It just manifests itself in a new form. Can I sue yet?
Report comment to moderator
Ken you are partially correct.
Yes it is true there is more black-on-black crime than there is black-on white. That is because most white people do their best to avoid blacks in their non-work spare time. Gated communities, private schools, living in suburbs 40 miles for the city are just a few of the precautions they take.
I suppose the part about “systematic and organized” white-on-black crime is true if only for the fact white people are more organized. But to say there has been more white-on-black crime throught the years than vice-versa is insane.
Report comment to moderator
Joshua Packwood was deserving of the honor (valedictorian) and this bothers those who are black? WHY, because he is brilliant? Or because he is white and brilliant?
Read the article in TIME, its the first link after you hit the one on this thread.
Report comment to moderator
9 – Pretty soon we’re going to hear people say, There’s just one sex – the human sex.
Oh, yeah – there are people already saying that.
Report comment to moderator
Bianca,
Point well taken, you made a HOME RUN with that one.
Report comment to moderator
Does it seem like blacks are more racist than whites these days? Hey Victoria, did you mean Newsweek, ’cause I can’t find one from TIME.
Report comment to moderator
Luke! It’s been I while! Welcome back. (I rather like your opinions, by the way. They make me think.)
Report comment to moderator
Opinionated teen
I blew it, yes its Newsweek. Did you read any of the article? Just curious to read your reaction.
Report comment to moderator
To Opinionated Teen
“Blacks are more racist than whites these days”?
“These days”? Blacks have always been more racist than whites. White people are pretty much content to run their own life and live in peace.
Black people always have to find someone else to blame for their problems and guess who they pick?
Rapes by white men of black women are practically non-existent.
Rapes by black women of white women are at an epidemic stage.
Report comment to moderator
Nick, I think you mean BM of WW.
Report comment to moderator
Mr. Peters: Perhaps. I’ll have to think about that one for a bit.
Victoria: Yep. I think it’s interesting how everyone makes a big stink about this EXCEPT the people actually involved. Did you read the second source? She’s completely racist!
Report comment to moderator
Whole lot of muck’s been dredged up, HSK.
Happy?
I guess it’s just a preview of the Republican playbook for ‘08.
It’s gonna be an ugly few months.
Report comment to moderator
Mr. Peters: I have talked to my parents and thought it through. What you said (”“Blacks are more racist than whites these days”?
“These days”? Blacks have always been more racist than whites. White people are pretty much content to run their own life and live in peace.) is not entirely true. People have always been racist, ALWAYS, whether they’re black, white, Aztec, Mongolian, or Japenese. It’s part of our sin nature to think that “Me and Mine are so much better than You and Yours”. To say that blacks have always been more racist than whites is unfair and incorrect.
Report comment to moderator
Welcome to our resident racist, Opinionated Teen.
Report comment to moderator
Opinionated teen
YOU WRITE:.. “Mr. Peters: I have talked to my parents and thought it through. What you said (”“Blacks are more racist than whites these days”?………….”
You are not giving YOUR VIEWS but those of your parents. I’m not interested in your parents views, this is a blog where adult people interact with oneanother, and not through a third party.
Many here are totally unbiased, or racially prejudiced. Whatever your parents feel are their BELIEFS, not the rest of the USA, or this blog.
Credibility starts with knowing enough to speak for YOURSELF, and realizing that without FIRST HAND KNOWLEDGE you won’t be taken seriously.
Report comment to moderator
Outkast, some things never change -
Report comment to moderator
Wow, well it’s what I would expect from, Nick. It’s a little refreshing to have him back really. I bet he an Night Train can trade statistics for hours without ever actually doing a google search, reading a journal article, or watching the news!
What’s even more inspiring is Vic-bold-Bible-quote-toria actually repremanding a teenager for talking to his/her parents? Yeah, I suppose that is the last thing we want kids doing these days!
Now OT, here is something fun to ask yourself when you are pondering racism. In what way are the behaviors I consider to be racist engendering an organized system of repression against a minority population by the majority?
It’s a whole wonder of self reflection.
And lest we all need a reminder, here is a link to “White Privilege: Unpacking the Invisible Knapsack”:http://tinyurl.com/58jmp
Report comment to moderator
Opinionated Teen,
Your approach of both talking to your parents for their insights and thinking it through yourself is a good one. In my eyes it gives you more credibility than if you tried to come up with an opinion without factoring in the perspective of people who have lived considerably longer than you have.
Report comment to moderator
Victoria, Opinionated Teen is to be commended for talking to his parents.
Report comment to moderator
Nick Peters: “White people are pretty much content to run their own life and live in peace.”
Except for when they were buying and selling black people in the slave trade.
Report comment to moderator
Kyle,
I think its great that teens talk to their parents, they should. However when they parrot what they say, not having first hand knowledge or background, based on life experiences, its based solely or largely on their parents ideas, not THEIR OWN.
I like OT, I have posted to him several times, but when he has to check with his parents to find out what they think so he can post,…. well you get the idea.
Report comment to moderator
Victoria: Shall I clear something up? My dad is also my pastor. I wanted a Biblical perspective. And I did NOT parrot what he said. I do thinking of my own, thank you.
Luke: I don’t quite understand. I’ll get back to you on that.
Pauline: Thank you!
Report comment to moderator
OT
It’s great that you can talk to your father, ask him questions, that is very different from what I was mentioning in reviewing your post #24 and then my post #26 “You are not giving YOUR VIEWS but those of your parents. I’m not interested in your parents views”.
That was not meant as a ‘put down’- perhaps I should have worded it differently, however life experiences are not the same as getting into a debate and then asking mom and dad for their take on it because you don’t know the answer. Your parents views are interesting, but it is YOUR view based on EXPERIENCE which is more important when posting, not that of your parents.
I do enjoy reading your posts as I have said before, you make some interesting points. By the way, my dad was a pastor too. I loved having my parents in the ministry, what a wonderful childhood I had. I bet you enjoy your life as a pastors child. You don’t have to answer but are you male or female, I hope you don’t mind my asking?
Report comment to moderator
Victoria: I didn’t take it as a put down. No worries.
Female.
Report comment to moderator
OP
I’m glad, I should have toned it down in post #26.
Report comment to moderator
OP, you remind me of myself when I was a teen, maybe that’s why I enjoy reading what you post, your ideas etc. Actually I went to my parents all the time with a jillion questions, I think my first sentence was a question and it NEVER STOPPED
Report comment to moderator
back to topJoin The Conversation
You need to be a registered user of WORLDonTheWeb.com to "join the conversation."
If you are not a member yet, what are you waiting for? Register / Login Now!