So, Ahmadinejad … you free for dinner?
Several religious groups invited Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad for a dinner in New York City this evening, sparking all kinds of reactions. The groups innocently state that they want to have an “interfaith dialogue” but some criticize the move as legitimizing a man who should be considered, well, an extremist.
He is president of a country where blasphemy against Islam is punishable by law—in fact, a law is in the works there to make it punishable by death.
On the surface, it may seem startling that Ahmadinejad would accept such an invitation. However, he is no doubt gunning for coverage as a “good guy” both in Iran and abroad.
The U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom called the dinner “counterproductive,” asking the religious sponsors to either cancel it or skip it. Commission Chair Felice Gaer told the Christian Science Monitor:
“I participated in a meeting with Mr. Ahmadinejad when the Council on Foreign Relations met with him. He really manipulates the veneer of being for peace, religion, and human rights in a way that is disgraceful.
“I am a great supporter and advocate of engagement. But you have to have somebody to engage with, and there has to be some sincerity. He laughs when you mention any problem situation and responds to questions with a question. … It’s a hypocritical exercise.”
The subject for the peace-mongering dinner: “Has not one God created us? The significance of religious contributions to peace.”
Representatives from the Mennonite Central Committee, the American Friends Service Committee, the World Council of Churches, and Religions for Peace plan to take part in the dinner.




Learn it! Speak it! Live it!
Bring Christmas to a child in need!








Click to Print
Include Comments











back to top18 Comments to “So, Ahmadinejad … you free for dinner?”
I watched about ten minutes of his speech to the UN. I could not distinguish between it and a sermon in any Christian church in the country. He spoke at considerable length about a loving god who created man from mud in his image and of one perfect person and of post-mortem life.
So yes, an inter-faith dialogue couldn’t hurt. Nobody is going to be converted, but perhaps the extensive commonalities of faith are a way to this man’s heart.
Report comment to moderator
I’d invite him over for pulled-pork sandwiches!
Report comment to moderator
We are always being told that Islam is a “religion of peace” so why not invite him?
I still say the reason Iran is our enemy is because they are Israel’s enemy.
And the U.S. never disagrees with Israel.
Report comment to moderator
Please read Mennonite Central Committee’s motivation and reasons for co-sponsoring this event tonight.
Go to http://mcc.org/news/news/article.html?id=394
and for specific questions and answers go to
http://mcc.org/iran/meetings2008/index.html
I appreciate MCC’s willingness to engage in loving dialog with our enemies even in the face of strong opposition. One of the core principles of the Anabaptist faith family is to follow the Biblical instruction to love all people as God loves us. This is not an easy commitment but I believe it is this Christian calling that MCC is attempting to be faithful to in this situation.
Thanks MCC!
Report comment to moderator
Brother Andrew was criticized for ministering to Hamas terrorists for a year when they were in prison. When they were let out (thank you Israel), they asked him to come and speak to them in Gaza. He preached a strong salvation message.
Even though all of that had no visible effect, it was an honorable thing to do. Loving one’s enemies is precisely what Jesus said to do.
However, there is a difference between treating an enemy with kindness and forgetting that he is your enemy.
Report comment to moderator
For what it’s worth, ancient Israel was also a place where blasphemy was punishable by death. Leviticus 24:16. And not just for Jews.
Report comment to moderator
How about some interfaith dialogue dinners among worldmagblog readers?
An evangelical Christian, a member of the religious right, an atheist, a liberal, a homosexual, Nick Peters or Night Train all sit down together for dinner.
I can be like a guy who is invited to a dinner party to fill in the empty place that needs to be filled.
Report comment to moderator
To Random Nane
As long as you pay for dinner.
Report comment to moderator
Random Name: And I’d pay good money just to come and watch.
(no food fights, though.)
Report comment to moderator
OK Nick, dinner’s on Donna. I’ll bring organic food from our garden as well. (We’re just finishing up our green beans at the moment.)
Our place is rather small, so maybe we’ll hold it at a church. Anybody have one to offer?
Also, I am very introverted, and quite shy, so I would probably be very quiet and mostly listen to everybody else.
Report comment to moderator
Hey, wait a minute here…..
Report comment to moderator
Arcadia must have missed the wiping the filthy Jewish nation off the earth and killing all Jewish Israelis part of what he thinks was a fine speech any Christian would give. Jeeze.
Report comment to moderator
#7 Random,
I have to love them adn poray for them. Thankfully, I don’t have to associate with you or them no harm intented.
Report comment to moderator
Llama: Here is the entire transcript of the speech:
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=6107339
The words “Jew” and “Jewish” appear nowhere therein. He does refer to the state of Israel, though not by name, and cites a version of history that paints them as oppressors. He does not directly call for the dismantling of the Israeli State (though he almost surely supports that) and does not call for the extermination of Israeli Jews.
Truly there is much to criticize about Ahmadinejad, but you do yourself no favors when you fabricate things from whole cloth.
Report comment to moderator
So what time’s dinner?
Report comment to moderator
“I could not distinguish between it and a sermon in any Christian church in the country.”
Apparently there’s no accounting for judgement or perspective in some circles. I can’t fathom the attraction some folks have to irrelevance. Maybe it’s an acquired taste, though I don’t understand this perpetual hankering for the kiddie table.
Report comment to moderator
Llama-
Here.
Take my keyboard. Really.
Here’s another lime for the tequila.
Report comment to moderator
Buddy Glass- 14
Thank you for linking to the transcript in 14. I had not seen it, mostly out of the Bush Bank Failure distraction and McCain waking up late for work and forgetting his homework scandal.
Report comment to moderator
back to topJoin The Conversation
You need to be a registered user of WORLDonTheWeb.com to "join the conversation."
If you are not a member yet, what are you waiting for? Register / Login Now!