Sweden, we have your number
WMB posted last week on how Horace Engdahl of the Nobel Prize jury has summarily judged all of American literature to be, not to mince words, insular and ignorant and unworthy of their attention. As you might imagine, the Americans have rebutted with their own criticisms. The general feeling among literary U.S. patriots can be described as two-pronged:
-
The Swedes, in this instance, are idiots.
-
The Swedes are ignoring the obvious, that European culture is mostly dead.
Here’s what one critic had to say:
As long as America could still be regarded as Europe’s backwater—as long as a poet like T.S. Eliot had to leave America for England in order to become famous enough to win the Nobel—it was easy to give American literature the occasional pat on the head. But now that the situation is reversed, and it is Europe that looks culturally, economically, and politically dependent on the United States, European pride can be assuaged only by pretending that American literature doesn’t exist. When Engdahl declares, “You can’t get away from the fact that Europe still is the center of the literary world,” there is a poignant echo of Gloria Swanson in Sunset Boulevard insisting that she is still big, it’s the pictures that got smaller.
I say: Invade Sweden. At least it won’t be a preemptive strike.


WORLD Magazine Library powered by Amazon
Term Life Insurance at Savings up to 75%!
Logos Bible Software for Bible Study


















back to top14 Comments to “Sweden, we have your number”
How do Swedish Ingmar Bergman abstract films compare in box office ticket receipts to let’s say “Dude, Where’s My Car?” Mightily poorly I’d conclude. The teen behind the counter at BLOCKBUSTER didnt even know who Bergman was.
Memorandum to Effete Eurosnobs: Dont hate us just because you couldnt invent Levis or Big Macs or MS Word.
Report comment as offensive
In your last blog entry you asked if this guy was just a snob. I almost replied that of course they were, what else do you expect? They (and their stateside sympathizers) have been going on about American’s terrible lack of culture for at least as long as we’ve been around. It’s time for ‘em to realize that their opinion is increasingly irrelevant.
We invented our own culture thank you very much…
Report comment as offensive
As some of you might surmise, my first post above was tongue in cheek in extremis. The book “Jihad vs McWorld” ( written before and updated after 9/11/01) went into great detail about how US movies dominate global film earnings. That brought to mind Stalin’s remark about how if he controlled all the world’s movie houses he could rule the world.
I think the French have sought to limit foreign film distribution in their country. Yet– with DVDs and internet simulcast–that does seem a bootless quest.
Report comment as offensive
Give “Mama Mia” an Oscar and the Swedes will pipe down
Report comment as offensive
European culture is mostly dead
America doesn’t have a culture. We have movies and video games and Facebook instead–but it’s not culture.
Franco Mortetti (sp?), Eliot critic, summarily dismisses all of postmodern literature and notes that in the modernist period–the last period of real literature–literature “mattered.” Today it doesn’t have cultural significance.
Report comment as offensive
The Norwegians say that the Swedes don’t need headstones. They just bury their dead from the neck down.
We have more fun.
Report comment as offensive
We should not invade Sweden, we’d get no benefits and all of their many liabilities.
Report comment as offensive
If there wasn’t a Sweden, worldmagblog would have to invent it, so they could diss it.
Report comment as offensive
If Mr. Engdahl is specific in pointing to the direction of American literary culture due to the Closing of the American Mind, I’d have to acknowledge him as a good critic, but it’s merely out of an European snobbery, then no kudos to him.
Report comment as offensive
But Random, they dissed us first!
Report comment as offensive
I once read in TIME a letter from a German. He was castigating the USA for wasting “all that oil” during the Viet Nam war.
I daresay our Kraut friends have wasted a few more barrels of petrol than have we in war time.
Report comment as offensive
#10 How do you say “diss” in Swedish?
#11 If the Iraq War was all about oil, as some critics allege, how much oil are we ahead?
How much wood would a would a woodchuck chuck if it drilled for oil or invaded Iraq?
Report comment as offensive
insular and ignorant and unworthy of their attention
Sounds about right. But I would apply it to almost all literature written in the last 50 years, or since the idea of transcendence was lost.
Report comment as offensive
Over on my blog, we’ve decided invading Sweden is a good idea because they have beautiful women.
Report comment as offensive