Unthankful for new recipes
My least favorite thing about Thanksgiving, and there’s not much to dislike about it, is the way food writers prostitute the convention of conventional Thanksgiving dinners by trying to reinvent it every year. As Regina Schrambling writes:
Every fall, writers and editors have to knock themselves out to come up with a gimmick—fast turkey, slow turkey, brined turkey, unbrined turkey—when the meal essentially has to stay the same.
And finally, she admits it: she does not follow all her own weird recipe innovations for alternative ways to use cranberry sauce, for Chinese sausage in rice dressing, for anything new. She admits, in short, that she is a hypocrite.
I make my stuffing as usual, roast my turkey as always, whisk up the same pan gravy, peel and mash potatoes, don’t get fancy with the cranberry sauce, and cook whatever green vegetable looks best at the farmers’ market. If I have time this year I’ll make pumpkin-thyme dinner rolls and the sweet potato-pecan pie I have baked 20 times before. It’s amazing how efficient you can be without new recipes.




Learn it! Speak it! Live it!
Bring Christmas to a child in need!








Click to Print
Include Comments











back to top22 Comments to “Unthankful for new recipes”
Is there a recipe for the sweet potato-pecan pie? That sounds good.
Report comment to moderator
Ah, but once someone introduced me to fried turkey, there was no going back…
Report comment to moderator
fast turkey, slow turkey, brined turkey, unbrined turkey
Tofurkey
Report comment to moderator
It’s amazing how efficient you can be without new recipes.
Aside from the efficiency issue, which is, of course, relevant to anyone who has to cook a lot, there is a reason that certain recipes are used so much – they’re favorites after all…
And what is Thanksgiving without my sister-in-law’s wonderful sweet potatoe souffle? Or my extravagant pecan pie?
Report comment to moderator
Trying new recipes is good when you haven’t yet found something you really like, or that your family really likes. Once you find their favorites, I’d say stick to them unless maybe you’re having an extra large crowd – then maybe add something new, like a second variety of cranberry relish (my father always made two, one cooked and one uncooked) or a different kind of pie.
I always make my turkey in a Reynold’s oven bag, and make my mashed potatoes the way I always have except with margarine now instead of butter (because my husband gets sick from eating butter since having bariatric surgery), but I haven’t yet settled on which recipe to use for the green bean casserole (my son’s favorite was the time I bought the Campbell’s frozen casserole) or the corn&cornbread casserole. And like my father, I make the two kinds of cranberry relish, but I’m still working on what I like in the raw version. And no pies anymore, since my husband can’t eat them since the surgery, and my sons aren’t big on pie.
I was going to try a chunky apple cranberry sauce, but now that we’re going to be eating at my husband’s aunt’s house, my contribution will be a big jar of mixed nuts from my son’s band fundraiser. Plus due to my husband’s work schedule being changed (he has to work tonight, 6 PM to 6 AM), we won’t even get there in time to eat with the rest of the family. (I’m sure there’ll be lots of leftovers, so we won’t go hungry.)
Report comment to moderator
New this year, a friend from Hawaii sent us Hershey kissed with macadamia nuts inside . . . and as I mentioned in WV, I’ll spend today trying to recreate an appetizer–asparagus spears wrapped in herbed cream cheese in a puff pastry.
My sister-in-law, a gourmet, is cooking, “because I only make this dinner once a year and since all my kids will be here and yours won’t, I’m doing Thanksgiving.”
Berry pie, pumpkin pie, appetizers and a relish tray. Oh, I just got assigned the vegetable, too. Easy.
Report comment to moderator
Pauline, the Reynolds oven bag is a wonder invention! I wouldn’t cook a turkey any other way.
Among other things, I’m bringing the mashed potatoes. Actually, our son is doing the mashing since he made the mistake of doing such a wonderful job last year.
Report comment to moderator
Tell me quickly about the Reynold’s oven bag. How do you use it? What is involved?
I am cooking the turkey tomorrow, but have never completely settled on the “best” way of doing that. I’m open to hearing about it while I can still run to the store!
Report comment to moderator
I have often wondered who actually makes all those strange new recipes that come out every year. Now I know who doesn’t (besides everyone else I know).
Report comment to moderator
TRS,
It’s real easy. Buy a bag the right size for your turkey (they’re generally sold with other bags such as sandwich bags and trash bags), it comes with directions. As I remember you put some flour in the bag, I think maybe they also suggest a stalk of celery (I might remember wrong), but I don’t use one if I don’t have any on hand. You put the turkey in, tie the bag shut with the plastic tie that is provided, and I think cut a few slits in the bag. Put it in a roasting pan big enough so the bag doesn’t hang out, and bake according to directions.
The turkey comes out incredibly moist, usually falling off the bones. My biggest problem has been to get the turkey onto a platter in one piece (making sure that the fork I stick in doesn’t just pull of a big chunk), and not making a big mess as it comes out of the bag. Some piece of skin inevitably sticks to the bag. And I’m trying to save the broth for soup, which is all in the bag to start with, but as I take the turkey out it goes all over the roasting pan, and sometimes the stove and the floor…
But the turkey tastes great, it’s very easy (no basting needed), and fairly easy cleanup because you just throw out the bag.
Report comment to moderator
I’ve done a turkey in the bag routine like Pauline, and I second her motion–very easy. Certainly easier for this mechanical incompetent than brining the bird in the cooler.
(You have to know how inept I am to understand . . . )
Report comment to moderator
Great news! I figured out the asparagus appetizer. Here’s the recipe:
Pepperidge Farm puff pastry–defrost, cut each sheet into nine squares.
In the meantime (it takes 40 minutes to defrost the puff pastry), heat oven to 400, steam asparagus spears, about three minutes, and then take out of the pot.
When you’re ready to go, mix one egg and a tablespoon of water together, as both a seal and a wash.
I used my finger and outlined the puff pastry square with the egg mixture. Put about a tablespoon of Bourin cheese–but cream cheese with herbs or something else like Rondele would work–and lay one asparagus spear on the angular fold. Fold into a triangle, sealing the edges (and the asparagus within, but a piece can peek out of the corner). Brush the rest of the egg mixture on top, pop them all into the oven for 15 minutes.
Oh, my! Delicious. This should be all we eat for lunch today . . . three each!
Report comment to moderator
I usually put butter/margarine over the bird in the bag as well. I also cut a small slit where the button pops out to give it room.
Report comment to moderator
I used a Reynolds bag (at my dad’s suggestion!) the one time I cooked a turkey for Thanksgiving. I was a senior in college, too far from home to go for such a short break, and my brother was a freshman at the same school. We invited some friends who also were at school over the break to my apartment, and I cooked dinner. Everything came out okay, as far as I can remember!
I married a man with a poultry allergy, so I haven’t had to cook a turkey again.
The years that we don’t go to my sister’s house, we cook a lamb roast or a ham instead.
Report comment to moderator
Michelle – 12
I copied your “asparagus appetizer” it sounds fab – we love asparagus – Thanks
can’t wait to try it.
Report comment to moderator
I always us my Webber grill. I cooks a little faster and it leaves the oven for dressing and pies.
I have cooked a turkey anyother way since 1980. Taste great and very juicey!
Report comment to moderator
TJ #2: amen to the deep-fried bird. Just making sure to pat the bird dry inside & outside to ensure no oil pops splash in your face, and it is SO deelish!
Michelle #12: I worked for some time as a banquet chef at a posh country club. One of the appetizers we served was very similar to what you described. It was a steamed asparagus wrapped in filo pastry and had finely grated asiago cheese in with the asparagus.
It was “Oh-my-goodness!” good..
Report comment to moderator
I just enjoyed the perfect pre Thanksgiving Thanksgiving meal. Eldest son and eldest daughter directed the hands and I did no cooking. Turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes and gravy, sweet potatoes, fruit salad, fresh baked rolls, extras, pies, etc. The kids did most of the dishes leaving me a few clean up details. Instead I was able to be outside pulling nails and picking up construction debris. And help the eight person crew lift the trusses up onto the roof. Excellent way to do things, I highly recommend it.
Our thing to be thankful for was when the one worker started to lose his balance and made a leap to safety from the roof to the floor and his fellow laborer lost his balance holding the truss, plummeting down headfirst toward the shower only to be saved by his glove being pinned by the truss. The others got him down safely and we all attributed thanks to God.
Report comment to moderator
Oh dear, I hit the post button before sharing this. I usually make a dressing made with oysters and wild mushrooms, as a side dish for dinner at my sister’s home.
Difference between stuffing and dressing: dressing is cooked and served outside the bird, which nowadays chefs are choosing instead of stuffing the bird, roasting and trying to drag the stuff out.
Report comment to moderator
Lloyd – 16
How long do you leave your turkey in the Webber? – do you cover it with foil? Your turkey must be very tasty
Report comment to moderator
#20
I cooked a 12-14 lbs bird Monday. It took just under 3 hours. I just rubbed it with butter and set it on the Grill. You put the charcoal on the sides with a pan of water in the middle. No foil is needed. When it’s done you push on the breast and see the juice bubbling. It was excellent. I like is better than the deep fried I will have at my daughters tomorrow.
Report comment to moderator
Report comment to moderator
back to topJoin The Conversation
You need to be a registered user of WORLDonTheWeb.com to "join the conversation."
If you are not a member yet, what are you waiting for? Register / Login Now!