Game-based military recruiting
Using video games to recruit soldiers isn’t new in concept, but this project is new in scale: I read in this morning’s New York Times that the military has replaced its five Philadelphia-area recruiting offices with a 14,500 square foot video arcade located in a retail shopping mall. The arcade, dubbed The Army Experience, features lots of shoot ‘em up games along with three full-sized Army simulators, an AH-64 Apache Longbow helicopter, an armed Humvee and a Black Hawk copter with M4 carbine assault rifles.
In recent years the Army has tried a number of ways to increase enlistment, including home video games, direct marketing promotions, a stronger online presence and recruitment-themed music videos. In 2007 it added bonuses of up to $2,000 for Army reservists who signed up new recruits. Civil liberties groups have criticized the Pentagon for its efforts to reach high school students.
But while recruitment remains strong in rural areas where there are military bases, it is weak in cities like Philadelphia, Major Dillard said. “The question is, how can we get our stories out to urban centers where most of the population lives, but where we don’t have a big presence?” he said.
Okay, I get that. And sources interviewed for the article go on to say that the center is as much about educating urban folk about the military as getting them to sign up. Not sure I buy that given the facility’s 22 onsite recruiters and the fact that recruiters generally work on quotas.
As a military veteran, I wonder if portraying military service as a chance to bring video games to life isn’t ethically questionable. I also wonder if it doesn’t appeal to the wrong motives for serving one’s country.
Read the rest of the story here.



WORLD Magazine Library powered by Amazon
Term Life Insurance at Savings up to 75%!
Logos Bible Software for Bible Study
Learn it! Speak it! Live it!
Free Hardcover ESV Study Bible!


















back to top16 Comments to “Game-based military recruiting”
Since the motto of all branches of the service is, “Hurry up and wait.” I hope these videos have long, boring periods in dull battleship gray and olive drab rooms. If you can’t sell your product staight up there’s a problem with your product. My son is in the Navy. He did his homework before he signed on the line and has very few surprise. But his biggest so far is that he apparently got the only honest recruiter in the country. At basic he could not believe what his mates believed and how their recruiters sold them down river.
Report comment to moderator
I have been exposed to a few rercruiting/interview situations in my time. They can almost never be completely honest because most job requirements change over time. Most of us are not doing (just) what we were hired to do.
Paint a positive picture of the military in recruiting. Many love the service and could not see themselves doing anything else, but they had to discover that as they grew into their jobs.
Report comment to moderator
Oh, the pacifists are gonna just LOVE this. I wonder when the Code Pink picketing will start.
Motives for joining the service have always been mixed. While we might wish it’s always out of pure selfless patriotism, I doubt we will get there.
The thing kids need to be aware of is that the military experience CAN be an adventure and worthwhile, but mostly if you land a cool military-style specialty, like a tank driver or fighter pilot. If you’re gonna join up and be a cook or a phlebotomist, It’s harder to see the point.
Report comment to moderator
Didn’t this happen in the movie ‘Toys’?
Report comment to moderator
Well, there are games, but there are also “three full-sized Army simulators, an AH-64 Apache Longbow helicopter, an armed Humvee and a Black Hawk copter with M4 carbine assault rifles.”
So I read this a little differently. Rather than “Using video games to recruit soldiers”, I would say it is an effort to bring realism to the recruiting process.
If you were to say, video games are used as a ploy to entice unsuspecting gamers and trick them into a career not of their own choosing, then obviously that would be unethical.
Having just gone through this with my son who is now a Marine, I must say that my perspective on military recruiting has done an about face. Contrary to my initial views, that recruiters were a pack of scheming liars, I must say that I was completely wrong.
My sons recruiters did not tell him anything that was incorrect. They did not trick him in any way. No one can truly prepare you for a Marine Drill Instructor in your face, but it wasn’t anything that was not clearly understood in advance. The parents and kids even got a taste of what a DI is like during a demonstration prior to leaving.
The Army and other branches of the military appear to be flush with cash. That is the real enticement. My son’s Army friend got a $20K sign on bonus and everything is paid for.
In the Marines, on the other hand, there is no bonus, low pay, old weapons and you have to buy all your own uniforms. No kid in his right mind would become a Marine unless he really wanted to. I realize that now. My son is proud to serve his country as a Devil Dog.
Report comment to moderator
America’s Army videogame tries to be as accurate as possible and inculcate Army ethics at the same time. It is extremely costly to the Army to recruit someone and then have them drop out, so it’s not in the Army’s interests to trick someone into enlisting. These video games help potential soldiers figure out if this is what appeals to them. They are painstakingly realistic in weaponry, doctrine, etc.
Report comment to moderator
This video game as a way to identify future combatants sounds familiar? Wasnt that the job of Centauri in “The Last Starfighter”?
I would go USAREC even one better. Build the video machines so that players dont have to feed it quarters to play. Instead, have them enter their identification data (driver’s license, SSN) and once they’ve done that let the machine run a full diagnostic skills test battery. The info could then later be sent to a Pentagon database
Report comment to moderator
#5 Xion,
Your story reminded me of when Frank Schaeffer’s son John was considering the USMC. Recruiters came to the Schaeffer home and explained all that would be demanded of young John. Frank’s wife at last asked “..and just what does my son get out of all of this?” The leatherneck was perplexed. “He’ll be a U.S. Marine, Ma’am!” Not “He’ll get Xthousand for college, a business start-up, a valuable post-corps career skill” Just had to laugh at that one.
Report comment to moderator
The Marines pretty much attract people by scaring them… and it works!
And Lynn, by “lots of shoot ‘em up games”, are you referring to typical arcade blam blam pretty colors and skimpy outfits fare? Or are you talking more like the “America’s Army” series, where it’s more realism-based?
Report comment to moderator
SawGunner and Cuthalion.
Report comment to moderator
Semper Fi.
Report comment to moderator
There was an episode about this on Johnny Test! That was a good episode, except for the global warming jargle.
Report comment to moderator
Lynn:
I’ve seen tons of CD-based video games given out for recruiting in the last five years. Apparently, it’s effective with the younger generation. Also, there are numerous weapons simulators on Army bases, i.e. huge videos games. It saves money on ammo, and weapons usage, as opposed to spending an entire day blowing through 20,000 rounds. Better save that for overseas.
I’m not crazy about huge cash bonuses, but in a recruiting industry that operates on numbers, it seems to work (probably greed-based).
I’d prefer an honor/duty based recruiting system…but I’m probably old-fashioned.
Report comment to moderator
My son played Call of Duty 4 incessantly prior to going to boot camp. Afterward he said that the weapons on COD4 were very true to life and he actually knew quite a bit about weapon capabilities, simply from playing the game.
Report comment to moderator
I was playing Call of Duty 4 with three friends once. We were in a competitive fight, sneaking around a ruined town, looking for each other, and hoping we’d see before we were seen. Someone made a comment about how freaky that would be in real life. For a couple minutes, we talked about that as we played. “No wonder they come back all messed up”, someone said…
Report comment to moderator
#15 I’m not a gamer, but I played COD4 on our PS3 once to humor my son. I got shot 30 times. The only person I killed was an accident because I dropped a hand grenade just as someone was killing me.
What is weird about modern games is they are online. So the people you are interacting with are actually real people. They don’t behave like computers at all. It took some getting used to. These games are very realistic.
Report comment to moderator