There was almost no room at the White House
A White House Christmas tradition, no matter which party’s in office, has been to prominently display a nativity scene in the East Room. But, as Eric Metaxas discovered while reading The New York Times Sunday Styles section, it almost didn’t happen this year. Seems that Desirée Rogers, the White House social secretary who has been in the news lately because of a certain recent party crashing, stated at a luncheon with previous social secretaries that the White House would have a “non-religious” Christmas this year. The article reported:
The lunch conversation inevitably turned to whether the White House would display its crèche, customarily placed in a prominent spot in the East Room. Ms. Rogers, this participant said, replied that the Obamas did not intend to put the manger scene on display — a remark that drew an audible gasp from the tight-knit social secretary sisterhood. (A White House official confirmed that there had been internal discussions about making Christmas more inclusive and whether to display the crèche.)
Yet in the end, tradition won out; the executive mansion is now decorated for the Christmas holiday, and the crèche is in its usual East Room spot.
Metaxas writes:
[T]he fact that it was going to happen reveals a level of political tone-deafness in the current administration that is staggering. To most average Americans — who did not grow up in an Ivy-League, inside-the-Beltway hothouse governed by the rules of the French Revolution — the idea of keeping Jesus out of “the people’s house” at Christmas evokes disturbing images of the Holy Family being turned away from the Inn, or worse yet, images of Herod. But to a super-secular White House afraid to offend anyone — except for average Americans — it probably just seemed like another fab “progressive” innovation.
If President Obama wanted to fuel the fears of every serious Christian in America and actually prove that he is every bad thing they’ve ever heard about him on every crazy Web site, the idea of symbolically taking Jesus out of the White House at Christmas would be just the ticket!

















Click to Print
Include Comments











back to top20 Comments to “There was almost no room at the White House”
He is who he is.
Report comment to moderator
It is hard to believe that this president takes his faith seriously when he takes great pains to dismiss anything that is Christian.
Don’t offend anyone…except Christians.
Report comment to moderator
“…the Obamas did not intend to put the manger scene on display…”
But they did so anyway because …
President Obama didn’t want … “to fuel the fears of every serious Christian in America and actually prove that he is every bad thing they’ve ever heard about him …”
Makes perfect sense. He isn’t yet ready to blow his cover.
Report comment to moderator
well the truth about Obama faith is coming out or lack of Christian Faith.
Report comment to moderator
I miss GWB at Christmas.
Report comment to moderator
Well, actually I am not sure that a creche, or any meaningful Christian symbology, would not be entirely out of place in this particular White house.
Perhaps Obama could more appropriately instead borrow the Ka’aba, the Black Rock in Mecca, and set it up in the East Room for his holiday observances.
Report comment to moderator
My only suprise is that he surcomed to presser and included it.
Report comment to moderator
Did they mention that the East Room will be closed in December for renovations?
Report comment to moderator
What’s hard to believe is that President Obama had any personal involvement with the great crèche debate of 2009! Let the man off the hook for this one, and I won’t hold him accountable for putting up a garish unseemly crèche in a federal building. Can we all act like grown ups this Christmas?
Report comment to moderator
“Perhaps Obama could more appropriately instead borrow the Ka’aba, the Black Rock in Mecca, and set it up in the East Room for his holiday observances.”
I don’t think it’s portable. Otherwise it’s politically unthinkable coming to America would certainly be quite a big deal…and (though it would certainly not fit in the East Room) certainly be a more impressive decoration than whatever crèche of inappropriate Caucasians is customarily set up in the White House.
Report comment to moderator
Mynock: Well, maybe Obama could get a special forces team to parachute into Mecca and knock off a luggage-size piece of the Ka’aba that would fit in the East Room.
Something tangible Obama could smooch and bow to, in order to feel better, whenever his advisers bring him the latest poll numbers.
Report comment to moderator
“I won’t hold him accountable for putting up a garish unseemly crèche in a federal building. Can we all act like grown ups this Christmas?”
I am sure you considered the Ramadan Dinner Obama hosted in that same federal building to be just as garish.
Report comment to moderator
Does it make a difference to the Lord Of All? I think not.
Report comment to moderator
#9 MyNock “Let the man off the hook for this one, and I won’t hold him accountable for putting up a garish unseemly crèche in a federal building. Can we all act like grown ups this Christmas?
Um, OK. Do you apply the same principles to Obama’s continual praise of Islam, teaching Arabic from the White House and making proud publicized celebrations of Islamic holidays?
What is your opinion of the word holiday (holy day) and should there be any Federal holy days?
Are you in favor of jettisoning America’s traditions and religious history for dull antiseptic political correctness?
Report comment to moderator
It’s already blown it, more and more citizens of the United States see it, which is reflected in the polls. I believe this individual will one day make a statement that will be as clear as glass.
Report comment to moderator
How pathetic that this is even a concern.
Report comment to moderator
Quote Roger #13:
“Does it make a difference to the Lord Of All? I think not.”
I think you are probably right, Roger.
Report comment to moderator
I’m still struggling to understand the phrase “a more inclusive Christmas”?
Better to ask what/whom has previously been excluded from celebrating it, and whyso?
What Orwell write about all the loopiness emanating from DC? A SITYS-style book?
Report comment to moderator
As we send young people overseas to fight and die against believers in one deadly myth, why incentivize the opposition by highlighting our own deadly myths?
The one certainty about all such myths is that other competing myths are considered the worst kind of poison.
Report comment to moderator
Arcadia
We are engaged in a war protecting Muslims from violent jihadis in their midst, (see other thread).
Some myths are purely myths, other putative myths are rooted in actual history. That there are competing and mutually exclusive religions has no bearing on the truth or falsity of any one of them. They clearly can’t all be right; it is a logical fallacy and sloppy thinking to infer that all are wrong.
The one certainty is that Arcadia will continue to misunderstand and misrepresent the competing world views of Christianity, Secularism, Islam et alia.
Report comment to moderator
back to topJoin The Conversation
You need to be a registered user of WORLDmag.com's Community section to "join the conversation."
If you are not a member yet, what are you waiting for? Register / Login Now!