Painful lessons
I forgot to grade my kids’ math assignments all week long last week. Yesterday I sat down to do just that, only to find that one of my girls missed a major concept on Tuesday and then repeated the same mistake twice on two different days the rest of the week. As a result, she failed the test on Friday.
Fortunately for her, I’m not holding her to those grades. It isn’t her fault that she repeated the same mistake; she was never corrected and told what needed to happen, so she kept doing what she had been doing, assuming it was the way it needed to be. I brought her in beside me and redid the first page while she was watching, slowly explaining the concept again. I then watched her as she redid the next page on her own, making sure she understood things this time. I also gave her the opportunity to redo all of those pages this week and retake the test this Friday. We’re both sure she will do much better.
Correction is nobody’s idea of a good time (I know it isn’t mine). Yet what happens when we’re allowed to continue on with our mistakes as though nothing was wrong? What happens if math concepts are missed, piano scales skipped through, and relationship basics ignored?
One word: failure. And often for what reason? Lack of feedback.
Repetition may build habits, but feedback is the breakfast of champions.
“No discipline seems pleasant at the time, but painful,” Hebrews 12:11 reminds us. “Later on, however, it produces a harvest of righteousness and peace for those who have been trained by it.”
It often isn’t fun being on either end of the correcting process. In my situation, grading math papers takes a fair amount of time—time that I apparently couldn’t fit in last week. But failing to do my part in our homeschooling education equation meant failure for my daughter to be able to do hers.
Sending out a long list of rule reminders to those in the homeschool group I direct was not a fun but necessary thing to do this week because, well everybody had gotten seriously lax.
Sitting at the table last week listening to my husband challenge me (again) about my shocking lack of attention to our family budget was not pleasant for either of us.
But all of it was necessary.
No discipline seems pleasant at the time. It is painful. It is painful to be told you are failing in an area and to know your behavior is causing frustration to another.
But what’s more painful is being allowed to sink further and further into those areas of struggle. There’s no love in that . . . just failure.

















Click to Print
Include Comments











back to top22 Comments to “Painful lessons”
No mention of God correcting us?
Report comment to moderator
No discipline seems pleasant at the time. It is painful. It is painful to be told you are failing in an area and to know your behavior is causing frustration to another.
Discipline does not have to be painful….
If I am doing something wrong I want to know about it. And the sooner the better.
If someone else is getting frustrated that is not necessarily my responsibility.
If I am the person doing the correction I usually don’t show ‘frustration’ to the person I am correcting.
Always correct in love and under prayer.
I strongly sense that a paradigm switch would be a good thing for your home schooling..
Report comment to moderator
Apparently, God thought discipline was painful, since that is what Paul wrote. It is painful for the one to find out that all her week’s work was not only wasted, but reinforced wrong. It is painful to realize you have to exercise your brain to correct it all. It could be frustrating to the reciever of such news. No one wants to be the bearer of bad news, although this is a very, very mild type.
Report comment to moderator
Reinforced wrongly.
Report comment to moderator
KI,
we are talking about straightening out some mathematics understanding. It is not scourging with a cat of nine tails. If Megan is using a cat of nine tails then perhaps she should change how she views the whole process.
I am curious at what level of mathematics she is teaching. Math can be and should be fun. A lot of times the student already realises that something is wrong with her understanding if the numbers don’t work out right.
Often in math it benefits us to look at a problem in more than one way. Often we start over to attempt to understand something. There is actually a joy when the concepts sync in. There is an ‘AHA ! moment.
If on the other hand you make it a terrible chore then you are in danger of putting a burden on the student that the student may not outgrow.
Math is fun. At least it is until someone makes us feel otherwise.
Report comment to moderator
I probably didn’t make it very clear that I wasn’t frustrated with my daughter for not understanding her math. I was frustrated with MYSELF for dropping the ball there.
But there are plenty of times my mistakes do cause justly deserved frustration to another (the budget example mentioned above). Sometimes I need to see how badly my actions affect someone else before I’m moved to change.
Sad, yes. But true.
Report comment to moderator
You made it very clear, Megan, and we from our house understand. It is the ripples in the pond after the stone is thrown.
Report comment to moderator
I understand what you mean about how our actions affect others. If I make errors it is possible that someone will suffer excessively.
For most of my life , I have done well. I have won more than enough awards for excellence to fill most houses.(Four bedroom house,) One of my motivations in all of this has been 2 Timothy 2:15 :Study to shew thyself approved unto God, a workman that needeth not to be ashamed, rightly dividing the word of truth.
Report comment to moderator
Practice makes improvement. Only God is perfect.
Report comment to moderator
Hey, Monty, remember us when you come into your Kingdom…
Report comment to moderator
Augustinian, I don’t understand your post.
Report comment to moderator
Monty,
Augustinian is just speaking for the rest of us who are grateful to be in contact with someone whose righteousness has exceeded that of the Pharisees.
Report comment to moderator
…or, should that be “self-righteousness”…
Report comment to moderator
Megan;
I got your point and it was very good. I too have been the author of frustration for my family. I used to joke that homeschooling was alot harder on the parent. It brings out our character flaws which in me there are many! The ticket is consistency which is probably my biggest fault. To help me with consistency I started the read your Bible in 90 days and I blog about it. It has kept my consistent.
God bless
Report comment to moderator
Megan, you have brought back memories of home school and the dreaded math papers to grade. And then grading of the correction papers. We ended up schooling through the summers to finish up math sometimes. One thing I found helpful was to have several math textbooks as backup in case a concept was not understood or if additional practice problems were needed. If understanding did not come from one textbook approach then the second book might do the trick. Oh, the wonders and joys of homeschooling which means additional work and a delayed payday coming at the distant future graduation from high school. It’s not for all but for the brave and optimistic it is feasible.
Report comment to moderator
NickG I would appreciate it if you would apologize. And if Augustinian is of the same mind I demand an apology from him also.
Report comment to moderator
Uh, MONTYFISHERWOOF: This is one of those times you graciously accept the criticism offered–an ability you implied you owned in your posts above.
Report comment to moderator
Always give room for further growth in awards…
..enough to fill a 5 room house.
Report comment to moderator
Megan
Your article was clear–no further clarification needed.
I am a former homeschooling mom–daughter graduated in 2005.
Report comment to moderator
I have done the exact same thing with my children’s Math. Yikes! I have really tried to be more consistent lately, even though I have been busier than ever lately. My aspiring astrophysicist wants to complete Calculus before she goes to College, so I have got to keep up. The good thing is that I understand Algebra now the second time around.
Such a concrete thing as allowing mistakes to go for even a week in Math, does make me think of how much worse it is if we have other mistakes and sins in our lives that are not corrected and allowed to slip. I am grateful for close friends who are willing to point out my faults to me when I need it. It’s painful and humbling, but so much better than keeping on and developing into bad habits and ingrained sins.
Report comment to moderator
I have been through the same experience with almost all of my children. It has taught me to grade work every single day – and that can take up to an hour depending on what they have done. It is hard to keep up sometimes with all the other things to be done.
The other thing that I have found I have to watch for is copying – yes, my children occasionally copy the solutions manual which I let them keep for reference. But, when I find that the answers look exactly like the solutions manual, then I have to take them aside and ask them to explain what they do. You would think that I would have learned to be more vigilant over the 17 years and counting, but sometimes it just slips in.
But, that is also the joy of homeschooling. We are able to stop and go back to correct the problem and not worry about the schedule that must be kept as I did when I was teaching math in public school. We have sometimes had to go back a couple of chapters just to make sure they understand what they missed the first time.
Also, when it comes to math, we have always kept it up through the summer. Usually, we will do half a lesson every day that we are home just so we don’t have to recover the brain after a summer off.
Report comment to moderator
blue here is the bword
red here is the r word
white here is the w word
blue back to b
wow
Report comment to moderator
back to topJoin The Conversation
You need to be a registered user of WORLDmag.com's Community section to "join the conversation."
If you are not a member yet, what are you waiting for? Register / Login Now!