What is real?
It’s a good thing I’m a Christian because the movie Inception was too close to the bone. I still have a tendency to struggle with the question “What is real?” The main things in life are resolved (God is real; I am God’s), but old tendencies manifest at 3 in the afternoon as I type a post on a sunny summer day and wonder if it is consequential in any ultimate way, or if working in the garden would be more real. Of course, if I were out in the garden, I would doubt that too.
There have always been movies asking about reality, meaning, perception, and time, but Inception is The Matrix on LSD. We have not one dream to contend with but three levels, plus layers of memory and flashback and psychological games—in other words, it’s a lot like your own life. In the indeterminate future (or is it the present?) Dom Cobb is a skilled “extractor” who invades other people’s dreams to steal secrets. He wants out, but for that he needs to do one last job, a mission of planting rather than purloining, something perhaps impossible.
My brother used to say, in our Buddhist days (about two weeks long): “If I dream that I am a butterfly, how do I know when I wake up that I am not a butterfly dreaming I’m a man?” After that we both became Christians, and not a moment too soon. Without the Scripture for a touchstone, we were ooze falling through ooze.
But Satan is the man of a thousand faces and reincarnations and turns up as an “extractor” and dream-planter in my renewed life. He has myriad ways, and you can read about some of them in C.S. Lewis’ The Screwtape Letters. Beware of distractions, contented worldliness, slippages from prayer, busyness, forays into nostalgia or regret, love of money, fear of man, Walter Mitty-fantasizing, materialism, bandwagons and noble causes, the long-term erosion of very small sins, theologies that induce complacency, addictions to food, addictions to sex, addictions to anything.
Like the great lion said to Jill:
“Remember, remember, remember the signs. Say then to yourself when you wake in the morning and when you lie down at night, and when you wake in the middle of the night. And whatever strange things may happen to you, let nothing turn your mind from following the signs. . . . I give you a warning. Here on the mountain, the air is clear and your mind is clear; as you drop down into Narnia the air will thicken. Take great care that it does not confuse your mind. And the signs which you have learned here will not look at all as you expect them to look, when you meet them there. That is why it is so important to know them by heart and pay no attention to appearances. Remember the signs and believe the signs. Nothing else matters. . . .”
There is a “totem” in Inception that the characters can consult when they are so turned around that they are hopelessly lost without a reliable plumb line of truth. I read the Scriptures more now than ever in my Christian life. It isn’t because I got more religious; it’s just because something tends to come over me around 3 o’clock in the afternoon.
To hear commentaries by Andrée Seu, click here.

















Click to Print
Include Comments











back to top5 Comments to “What is real?”
Interesting! I liked the Matrix for the same reason, showing that the real world is much larger than our physical every day lives.
It made me think about the spiritual world behind the scenes. Of course, I had to extract that meta-story out of the soupy mish-mash of quasi-religious gruel and unbelievably bad acting, but it was worth it!
P.S. If you really want to understand Screwtape Letters, get the audio book version narrated by John Cleese of Monty Python fame. I never fully understood the book until I heard him read it. Fantastic! Very highly recommended! He had me in stitches!
Report comment to moderator
I haven’t seen the movie. I doesn’t really interest me. While Satan does have many disguises, he has only one technique, lies. Even when he tells the truth it is for a lie. God’s Truth, while deep and marvelous and sometimes bewildering, has the sense of reality that fits both the simplicity and complexity of human life. Thus, grounded in the Word, our afternoon (or midnight) daydreams can be put into perspective where the simple joys of loving and being loved can grow and flourish in solid reality. “Grounded in the Word” is the key ingredient, for reality is certainly not the product of our easily manipulated human mind.
Report comment to moderator
We saw the movie the other night and I got completely lost–like in a dream. I found it disturbing on several levels, but I also got bored. (All that blowing up, mayhem and violence is starting to get really old.)
What we found intriguing is, we saw the ending two different ways–one thought it was happily ever after, the other thought it was a mere dream.
But I agree with Andree, it did hit too close to home in several spots. Using the Bible as a “totem” is the only answer.
Report comment to moderator
Years ago I used to practice “lucid dreaming”. By learning and practicing a few simple techniques it’s possible to train yourself to recognize when you are in a dream and to “take over” the dream and do pretty much whatever you want. Most of the time when I realized I was in a dream I would immediately take off like superman leaving behind whatever it was that I was dreaming about.
The technique I used to initiate lucid dreams involves making a habit of reading something, looking away for a couple of seconds, than looking back at it to see if it still says the same thing. I would practice this five or ten times a day to get in the habit of doing it so that eventually I would do it in my dreams. I remember the first time I looked back and the sign said something completely different; I knew I was in a dream.
I stopped doing it because I would generally only get a short period of lucid dreaming before it woke me up. I decided I liked sleeping more than lucid dreaming.
In my opinion, the really far out aspect of Inception is the concept of shared dreams. The interactions of millions of neurons transporting information from one area of the brain to another where it then interacts in an almost holographic way is so subtle and complex that it would take far more than some portable machine and some sedatives to allow participants to share a dream. Fortunately the filmmakers didn’t get hung up on trying to explain the technology.
Report comment to moderator
#4: “Fortunately the filmmakers didn’t get hung up on trying to explain the technology. ”
Which leaves the entire story wholly in the realm of fantasy. Someone said Inception throws so much at you that it is difficult to comprehend in one viewing. I came to the conclusion that it was not necessary to comprehend it, just to enjoy an interesting story. (And yes, the guns and explosions did get stale. I guess I wouldn’t like some people’s dreams.)
But it is an analogy for the uncertainties of our own lives, and helpful to understand where (who) our anchor is.
Report comment to moderator
back to topJoin The Conversation
You need to be a registered user of WORLDmag.com's Community section to "join the conversation."
If you are not a member yet, what are you waiting for? Register / Login Now!