What remains
Today I attended the burial of a child. It is a bitter, hard thing, the death of a child. It is especially so in modern America, insulated as we are from the brutalities of history and the depredations in much of the world. We are not accustomed to burying our children, any more than we are accustomed to the thunder of approaching war or the desperate ache of searching for clean water and a scrap of food. We have outgrown the world and history and forgotten much about suffering. Perhaps this is why we have also drifted from God.
But sometimes the fallen world finds even us, and so we get ourselves used to a wheelchair or fend off memories of a rape or gather with friends beside a narrow slit in the earth into which we will lay the body of a baby.
I am thankful it was a body. Something I regret, after our own child died, is that we had her body cremated. We didn’t know any better. We believed the body is just a shell, that all she was had passed into Heaven. We practiced a sort of cognitive dissonance, believing both that the human body is created in the image and likeness of God and that it is a temple, and yet also believing that the totality of the person is spiritual, that the body is a sort of machine or dwelling place.
And so we gave her over to be burned to ashes. This was not always a practice accepted by Christians. But like so many other things we have forgotten the old ways. There was a time when the body was considered sacred, even after life had departed from it. But economic pressures and influence from pagan cultures led us to convince ourselves that cremation is acceptable. It’s certainly cheaper today than burying a body.
I am glad our friends chose to bury their baby’s body, to refrain from doing violence to that precious creation so fresh from God. There is something right, I have come to believe in the years since my daughter’s death, in treating the body that remains with reverence. It is right to place it into the ground in faith that it will be raised up, that our physicality is part of who we are, that we are more than just spirit-children briefly inhabiting fleshly husks.
It is a hard cruel thing, closing the lid on your child’s coffin. What no one tells you is that in the months and years to come, people will forget, but you will not. Something in you has died as well, and it awaits resurrection with your child’s body. You will carry this hole in you all your days, and there are no words or heavenly equations to make it good, not so long as you breathe while your child does not.
My wife and I cannot tell our friends this yet, because it does them no good to know it. But we were able to tell them how deeply we regretted cremation, and now we thank God they heard us. You ponder every second you had, questioning if you could have done something differently while your child was living. To lose someone close to you is to wrestle forever with regrets. At least they will be spared this regret, which is no small thing. But still there is the long dark road ahead. Pray for them.

















Click to Print
Include Comments











back to top30 Comments to “What remains”
Tony, if it’s worth anything, I think others may in fact remember and sorrow with you more than they tell you. I have friends who buried their toddler daughter at Easter several years ago, and I never think of them without a tinge of sorrow at their loss (though I myself have ever borne a child, let alone buried one), and I think of them in the Easter season as well, and I never met this child. How much more do those who knew and loved her (or your daughter) still remember, I am sure.
I prayed for your friends after reading this. May they know God’s healing, and may those around them say the right things, love with the right actions, and be restrained from saying the wrong things.
Report comment to moderator
Praying.
God has never taken us down this road, for which I am grateful. We have seen it in others and it is deep. The wailing of a young mother losing her child through miscarriage, another couple losing one through illness, others losing to the stupid actions of almost adults, and my own dad’s sorrow at the death of his oldest daughter to the mistakes of a surgeon when she was 49. He said that a parent never expects to outlive any of his children, it should not be. But it is.
Report comment to moderator
Grief takes time, sometimes a long time. Cheryl is right. I am remembering a little one 18 mos old killed by a drunk driver, and the tears still well up. This is when we should be grateful for the time that God has given us to touch others as we have been touched by those departed from us.
Report comment to moderator
Lord have mercy. May the memory of this child (and yours as well, of course, Tony) be eternal.
Report comment to moderator
Do cementaries still face gravesites towards the east so that the dead will rise facing the Christ when he returns?
Report comment to moderator
Didn’t know that, but my parents are like that. Other sections don’t face east.
Report comment to moderator
I recently received an issue of the Ivy League Christian Observer. ILCO publicizes various parachurch ministries at the various Ivy League schools.
The current issue has an article about Mary Cunningham Agee. She was literally at the top of her corporate financier game. She had been a Christian all along but the miscarriage of her first child hit her quite hard. Out of that experience she was able to start an amazing nonprofit support group.
I’ve not known miscarriage. All our kids came out wonderfully blessedly healthy (the last via C-section). But all around me I have friends who experienced fetal demise en utero or shortly after delivery.
And late night TV funnymen Ed McMahan and Johnny Carson ea endured the death of a child.
Report comment to moderator
I do remember those who have died young, a nephew, a brother, a half-brother, a friend’s child, etc. and think about them.
In the old days we buried our loved ones on personal property, or in the church yard. We also didn’t spend thousands of dollars to bury someone.
I don’t know about cremation. It is puzzling.
Our family of 3 are slated for cremation.
Will God not call us because we don’t have a resting place in the ground?
Report comment to moderator
I have no doubt that God can give us a resurrected body no matter what. The sea will give up her dead, too.
Report comment to moderator
Of course God can.
The question is one of symbolism, I think. And, so, I do agree with Tony. I do not wish to be cremated, nor would I have my children cremated.
Report comment to moderator
Funerals and cemeteries are for the living, not the dead.
Report comment to moderator
njlawyer: You say, “Funerals and cemeteries are for the living, not the dead.”
Which reminds me of Matthew 22:31-32: And as for the resurrection of the dead, have you not read what was said to you by God: ‘I am the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob’? He is not God of the dead, but of the living.
Report comment to moderator
So, along the lines of “it is desecrating the body to cremate”? When disposing of old flags, they are burned. Isn’t that what is supposed to happen (not legalistically, but respectfully) when the Bible is worn out? I am not an advocate of cremation, though I do not have any concerns about God resurrecting us in whatever condition.
Report comment to moderator
#5 NOPM — Yes I believe this is still the practice in the Orthodox cemeteries. I’ve been to one Orthodox funeral; it was a small one with a dozen or so people in attendance. It was a very windy day, and the people in attendance were honestly just trying to hold things down; the priest trying to hold onto his service book, censer, etc. (I was in the car with a baby, so was watching all this from the wind-free zone). The casket was lowered into the ground, and then I saw a parishioner go over and whisper in the priest’s ear. Just after, the men lifted the casket back out and spun it around. The reposed’s head had been toward east, her feet to the west; they turned her so that she was facing east.
Report comment to moderator
“Spun” does not give the proper mental image, to be sure. “The men lifted the casket out and carefully turned it around the other way.” That’s better.
Report comment to moderator
I think funerals are for the living, but burial is also for the dead (as is cremation, for those who choose that route–I wouldn’t). Since indeed the body is part of the person, burial is the last act of love we do for that person.
Report comment to moderator
Very moving and thought provoking, thank you.
My father is buried in a national cemetery here in my home state in a section with many Vietnam and WWII veterans. Very close by his site, oddly enough, is the grave of an infant, who apparently was the child of a soldier on active duty. Although I knew national cemeteries were open to the immediate family of service members, I never really thought of a child being interred in one, but in a way, I think it’s kind of neat and comforting that a family chose to have their little one placed there, surrounded by her countrymen, however sad the circumstances may have been.
Apparently the child died before birth or shortly thereafter, because there is no name on the stone, only that of the parents (which I don’t really remember). It reads simply:
“Infant”
“Daughter of SSgt. John and Jane Doe”
“U.S. Army”
and one date
Very moving…..
Report comment to moderator
My husband is giving his body to science and we are to cremate whatever they don’t want? I don’t know. I would think they would keep the whole body. He signed some papers for that.
Report comment to moderator
I am not suggesting desecration of remains. If I were, I wouldn’t be so opposed to the mosque near the WTC. But I thank Mrs. Edwards for the citation in #12.
We worship Christ not only for hanging on the cross for our sins, but also because of the empty tomb.
As an aside, my sister and I did not know the difference between headstones and footstones. We thought footstones were flt versions of headstones put in to maintain the grounds more easily when mowing the lawn. In other words, we thought the footstones ws at the head, and until our mother died, we “talked” to our dad’s “neighbor” when we visited the cemetery. We both apologized to him.
Report comment to moderator
Tony, Great piece. This is why I’m a Woodlief fan.
Report comment to moderator
My wife and I talked between ourselves about cremation without coming to any definite conclusion. I believe the Creator of the universe is capable of reconstructing our bodies in whatever condition they may be after our death. Think, for example, of individuals blown to bits by bombs, people drowned and (super-ugh!) eaten by fish, ashes scattered over large expanses of land or even mingled with the ashes of other people as in a huge fire. No, nothing is impossible with God (Luke 1:37).
When we floated the idea before our daughter she was visibly shaken, almost to tears. She knows Scripture as well as we do but she wanted someplace to “go to,” that remembrance might be more real.
We dropped the idea of cremation out of respect for her.
Ken Bland
Report comment to moderator
Okay, NJL, now I have to do research. I didn’t know a thing about footstones, and assumed the very same thing that you and your sister did!
Report comment to moderator
If you are interested:
http://www.opc.org/qa.html?question_id=347
http://www.opc.org/nh.html?article_id=237
Report comment to moderator
We felt a little stupid, but we didn’t know. I have to say it was strange to find out we’d been “talking” to the wrong person all those years, but it answered something that always bothered me. Our aunts and uncles are in the same cemetery and I always wondered why they planted trees the way they did because it seemed as if the trees were right on the graves. I felt better after learning about footstones.
Let me know if you find out anything else.
Report comment to moderator
I have known many young people who have died, including a three year old cousin who lived with us for the three months before he died. We have friends who just buried their third child, although he was in his early forties. Our daughter’s boyfriend was twenty when he and another friend died in an accident. I have learned there is no closure or getting over—just going on.
My parent’s are insisting on cremation. It is purely a financial decision and we will respect it. I don’t like it myself, but know God will resurrect me whatever is done with my body. It is no problem for him.
Report comment to moderator
Way too close to home. Burying my Mom on Wednesday..
I tend to agree that wakes, funerals and burials are for the living, not the dead. I also dislike the idea of cremation, but that’s because I don’t think you get the same sort of closure as with knowing taht the body is still there.
Honestly, I also don’t agree with the whole symbolism on cremation vs burial. Even buried, the body decays, and the actual atoms that make us up are dispersed over the millenia.
When I read the Bible, and I see “Then I saw a new heaven and a new earth, for the first heaven and the first earth had passed away..” I see a re-creation, not a re-cycling or a re-use.
So I do see a physically resurrected or re-created body, since “though after my skin worms destroy this body, yet in my flesh shall I see God”, but think that He has no trouble creating this new flesh regardless what becomes of the old, whether buried at land or see, burnt, or, as I think I might choose, donated for research.
Report comment to moderator
Roy, so sorry about the loss of your mother.
Report comment to moderator
My condolences, RoyClay. She’ll always be with you.
Report comment to moderator
Roy, may her memory be eternal.
Report comment to moderator
I am an atheist, but I have lost a child. Your paragraph about the hole in your heart is the absolute truth and I will keep that paragraph to re-read whenever I am having a bad day. It’s been 8 years, but it never ends.
We decided to cremate our son. The thought of him in the ground, rotting, was exquisitely painful. I knew I would imagine what was going on in that casket as the weeks and months passed. So we cremated him and buried his ashes with his grandfather. I’ve never regretted it.
Report comment to moderator
back to topJoin The Conversation
You need to be a registered user of WORLDmag.com's Community section to "join the conversation."
If you are not a member yet, what are you waiting for? Register / Login Now!