A freshman, not a rookie
GRAND RAPIDS, Mich.—Rep.-elect Bill Huizenga is a freshman Republican congressman who will assume the seat held for 18 years by Peter Hoekstra. Their Western Michigan district is mostly Republican, white, and Protestant.
In an interview, I asked Huizenga what he thinks of Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s intention to run for minority leader. “I guess we can only hope she wins, because it’s going to cement our majority,” he says with some delight.
Pelosi’s post-election comments indicate she is seeking vindication for healthcare legislation, stimulus spending, and other bills she and her Democratic congressional colleagues pushed through at warp speed.
Pelosi and President Obama do not see the midterm election results as a referendum on their policies, but rather as a communications failure. Predictably, Huizenga sees it otherwise. “I don’t see how anybody can honestly interpret the election and say this was an affirmation of what they’ve done and that they just didn’t get their message out,” he says.
Huizenga speaks from experience. When he was a member of the Michigan legislature, Republicans went from minority to majority and Democrats kept the person who had been speaker as minority leader. “It did not help communication at all,” he says, “because it sent a lot of signals. The same personality conflicts were in place and probably were heightened. I understand how [Pelosi] can win this; I don’t see how someone who is one of the most divisive political leaders in recent times is suddenly going to turn on a dime and lead a parade of bipartisanism.”
Huizenga says what Republicans are proposing has elements of substance and symbolism but that “we need to have both.” He says, “We need to send a message to the American people that we get it; we understand what they are going through.”
Reforming the healthcare law is the top priority for incoming and established Republicans. Huizenga admits that lacking a Senate majority, much less the 60-vote margin needed to pass anything in the Senate and a president who is unlikely to sign any bill that would dismantle his premiere issue; the law will probably not be quickly repealed. But, he says, “It sets things up for the 2012 presidential election, as well as congressional elections.”
The 2010 election has been described as an audition, or probation, for Republican freshmen to prove they meant what they said during the campaign and to demonstrate they are different from the previous Republican majority Congress, which resembled Democrat-lite.
What about social issues like abortion, same-sex marriage, and gays in the military? Polls show voters have less concern about these issues than the economy, or even terrorism. Huizenga, who is pro-life, says the abortion issue will have to be attacked at the margins for now. He wants to add restrictions on abortion to the health insurance reform law and thinks the old coalition of fiscal and social conservatives that served Ronald Reagan well can be revived.
Having worked in Washington before, Huizenga says he’s aware of the disease called “Potomac Fever.” How does he intend to inoculate himself against it? By maintaining roots in Western Michigan, he says, and by keeping to a schedule of three days in Washington, four days in his home state.
Has he figured out a way to respond to attacks by Democrats that Republicans only care for the rich? “We have to live our lives in ways that demonstrate compassionate conservatism,” he says. Huizenga and his wife are involved in organizations that help the homeless “and other things. My argument is that instead of expecting the federal or state governments to step in and have that as their role, it has to start with me as an individual, my church, my community, and I’d better set the example.”
Politicians have been setting an example. Unfortunately, for too many, the examples have been bad ones. Perhaps Bill Huizenga, whose background is in small business, will be different. It helps that while he will be a freshman member of Congress, he’s not a rookie.
© 2010 Tribune Media Services Inc.

















Click to Print
Include Comments











back to top2 Comments to “A freshman, not a rookie”
Republicans are making a big mistake if they think that the midterm was a referendum on health insurance reform. If they keep talking about repeal, they are going to have a hard time in the Presidential election explaining to people why they want to make it legal for insurance companies to deny people with pre-existing conditions, to cut peoples insurance when they get sick, to tell parents their 1 year old has exhausted his life-time limit, to kick all the 24-26 year olds off of their parents plan. Good luck with that.
On a personal note, I just had to switch from Kaiser to Blue Shield and now I know from personal experience that we DO NOT have the greatest healthcare system in the world. Far from it. People speak of the dangerous of “socialized medicine” in long lines and wait times. But that obscures how dysfunctional our system is. Recently I need a throat culture for a sore throat. And though I pay almost $350 a month in insurance premiums I was still told by 7 different doctors that my only option to get a culture would be to go to a walk-in clinic where I would have to wait in a huge line and not get service at all if all the appointments were filled up by people before me.
Re: Pelosi, “I asked Huizenga what he thinks of Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s intention to run for minority leader. “I guess we can only hope she wins, because it’s going to cement our majority,” he says with some delight.”
The GOP tried in 2006 and 2008 to demonize Nancy and her “San Francisco values.” Neither attempt was successful. She may not be personally popular, but the midterm was not a referendum on her leadership. And she was minority leader when the GOP lost the majority in the first place. I would put good money on her being speaker again by 2012. It’s a volatile electorate. Dem’s need to only gain 25 seats to retake the majority. Reps will be defending vulnerable seats in California, Oregon, Washington, Colorado, New York, Illinois, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, Minnesota, and Michigan during a Presidential year…and you don’t have a candidate.
Plus, I doubt congresses approval score is going to go anywhere but down under Boehner and Cantor’s leadership. First question in any press conference for John Boehner should be, “Does part of your effort to cut government spending include finally allowing the Pentagon to stop buying redundant plane engines from the companies in your district?”
Report comment to moderator
I wonder how much of this we’re going to be seeing, these optimistic post-election profiles of Republicans riding the wave of [insert whatever reason you think Rs won and Ds lost here] into Congress. It’s not that I think conservative commentators should be grouchy, but history shows they should be skeptical. They should be less giddy, more discerning, and more demanding. Save puff pieces until the Rs actually do something.
Report comment to moderator
back to topJoin The Conversation
You need to be a registered user of WORLDmag.com's Community section to "join the conversation."
If you are not a member yet, what are you waiting for? Register / Login Now!