A helpful film
With the exception of, say, Julie and Julia, books are generally better than the movies based on them, right? It’s almost impossible to capture the entire essence of the printed word in two hours or less.
Earlier this week, my family was invited to a screening of The Help, and having read the book earlier this year, I had high hopes for the movie but a nagging fear that it would not live up to my expectations.
As it turns out, The Help was no different from most book-to-movie adaptations in that some things were left out, but those missing pieces did not diminish the stirring, heartbreaking, yet hopeful story of domestic life that took place during the 1960s civil rights struggle in Mississippi. (Warning: The film does contain a lot of vulgar language.)
Raised in our modern day culture, my kids are vaguely aware of the notion of racial tension, but they have never been personally confronted with it. Although my girls have an understanding of the history behind the issue—we’ve read books together like Roll of Thunder, Hear My Cry, and biographies of Martin Luther King Jr. and Rosa Parks—they have very little firsthand experience with the emotion attached to the issue or the hatred involved, and thus have a hard time understanding it as a concept.
Taking the girls to see The Help helped them understand just how serious, sad, and senseless the racial divide was in 1960s America. There was more than one tear shed among us as we watched how the white women portrayed in the film so poorly treated their black house help. We also felt the tension of the white women not being present with their own children, which in turn created a bond between the children and the black women who actually raised them, causing confusion for all.
As the film credits rolled, we sat silent for a while before leaving the theater. My oldest daughter gave me a look of disbelief as she asked if that was really how some white people treated black people back then. I assured her that in some cases it was all that and worse. She shook her head in anger: “That’s just . . . so . . . wrong.”
Agreeing, I explained that while we’ve come a long way in redeeming race relations since the 1960s, we still have a long way to go. I believe true reconciliation among the races will never be final this side of heaven. Once glorified we will finally fully realize that “there is neither Jew nor Greek, slave nor free, male nor female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus” (Galatians 3:28).
Still, with young hearts and minds stirred by movies like The Help and, most importantly, informed and transformed by the Gospel, perhaps we can see God’s Kingdom come and His will be done now, on earth as it is in heaven.
At least that’s what I prayed for my girls on Monday night.

















Click to Print
Include Comments











back to top15 Comments to “A helpful film”
Actualy history is always a very mixed bag (all the extremes and moderated cases included), but movies about history are usually about as unmixed as you can get–the stark black & white formula here seems to be: whites = evil (with an exception or two) and blacks = good. Fine. That’s a rather safe formula to use today to entertain people. Again, fine. But I lived through all the 60s and I completely relate, emotionally, to the horror and shock that MEGAN’s oldest daughter felt, and I only saw the preview.
I am just as outraged over the evil of racism when I see it as can be but I am not so foolish as to think that a movie can represent reality (or history) fairly. And it would be wrong to walk away from this movie resenting or hating a race or to walk away from it in shock to see that human beings are desperately fallen as sinners. We should know that going in.
Report comment to moderator
*Actual.
Report comment to moderator
The movie looks interesting. It is not something that would normally be on my radar.
As for books vs. movies: It is almost always true that the book is better, but I’ve run into a few exceptions.
One example? “The Apple Dumpling Gang” was WAY better and funnier as a movie than it was as book!
Report comment to moderator
Roll of Thunder, Hear My Cry
Funny story. In the third grade (one year after I had been bussed to a different elementary school because of a federal court order ordering my district to better integrate its schools) my teacher, who was black, suggested this book to me. Knowing only the title, the first words out of my mouth were an excited, “Is it about fighter jets!?” She was a patient woman.
Report comment to moderator
The horrible way that some people looked at African-Americans in the past is matched and surpassed today by the horrible and dehumanizing way that most Americans regard babies and children of all races. If we don’t rip them apart in the womb for reasons of convenience, many of us at least do all they can to make sure children do not grow up in homes with a mom and dad living and loving together. We use gov’t money to pervert them and we have more socially acceptable ways than ever to make them fatherless and/or abandon them and/or ingore their real needs.
Report comment to moderator
I remember the shock I felt as a teenager seeing “Whites Only” signs at the Smithsonian. I knew that segregation existed, but having the evidence before my eyes was powerful.
I remember also moving to the South and going to a new school. I was surprised to hear kids talking about when the black kids came over to the white school, because I had always gone to integrated schools before. I could not wrap my head around the concept of a “white” school and a “black” school.
Worse than that were white churches and black churches.
At the white church we attended my mother was teaching a Sunday school class, and one of her young students was surprised to see a picture of an African child in the story paper. “Black people don’t believe in God,” he said.
I remember when my siblings and I missed the bus on the first day of school, and the black principal drove us home. My mother invited him in for some iced tea, and he was reluctant to come in the house. He told my mother that she didn’t really want him to come in because the neighbors might see it. She said, loudly, “I don’t care what any of them think. It’s my house and you are welcome. Any of them that don’t like it, aren’t welcome.” I was amazed, because my parents had always had black friends who visited us before.
I remember being puzzled that white people didn’t mind if the food in the school cafeteria was prepared by black ladies, but they would not allow black people to swim in the pool at the Lions Club park. If they could touch the food, how would they contaminate the water?
I remember when one of my white friends went to college with his black girlfriend. They were not allowed to attend his church, and his family basically disowned him.
I’m glad that things are better now. We are not all the way there yet, but we are getting where we need to be. MLK’s dream has not come true completely, but it is coming true.
Report comment to moderator
I’m only 26, so I have no clue what it was like to live during the 1960’s. I did grow up in St. Louis, though, and went to a Christian highschool that was very racially mixed. Sometimes, there was little bit of tension, nothing major, and only between individuals. Most times, the white kids wanted to imitate the black kids and what they wore and how they talked.
Technically speaking, there is one race, the human race. We just all look different.
“The Help” was a very good book. It will be interesting to see the movie, as the actresses playing Skeeter and Hilly are not ones I would expect, and I hope that their prior roles don’t make seeing them in “The Help” a hindrance to me.
Report comment to moderator
I always attended integrated schools and other clubs and activities.
My parents were against interracial marriage, but were otherwise very non-racist.
I don’t have a problem with interracial marriage, so my kids don’t even have that.
Living on the West Coast, and having grown up with every sort of ethnic mix of friends, I am always surprised that it is still such an issue for some people.
Report comment to moderator
I was born in Biloxi, Mississippi and went to Jefferson Davis Elementary School at the very time MLK was marching at the time, but I never heard about it. It is still the strangest thing to me, it motivates me to really want to know the black experience because I was there at that important time and yet I was so removed from it.
But perhaps it was that we had our own particular culture at Keesler AFB, and my parents were well-educated and from a big urbane city on the West Coast and had not a racist bone in their bodies. We had a black housekeeper for my overwhelmed mother, and she was a great source of comfort to us children. Hearing those southern drawls on the trailers brings me to tears, they speak to me of soothing.
So the first racism I ever encountered when we were transferred to Bellevue Nebraska, and the only black girl in the whole school was jeered at, and then later their home was burned down. Probably from that same boy who instigated her shunning. The family escaped alive, but they left town. I still remember her face, at the moment of her humiliation. It is seared in my memory.
Now I am a devoted auntie to three adoptees from Ethiopia, my daughter is dating a young black man, and my kids best friends are bi-racial. And no-one thinks a thing about it.
Report comment to moderator
The 60s were a hugely immoral decade with most social changes being made for the worse. But the progress made against racism was the positive exception. Major laws and attitudes regarding race were changed in that decade. It took more courage to stand against racism in the 60s and millions of of Americans did take such stands. Exceptions abound, but civil rights laws were passed because the American people had reached the point where politicians finally followed suit. I don’t buy the myth that heroic and sacrificial politicians led the way–politicians almost always follow the people. But Hubert Humphrey was an exception. He stood against the long-standing racist attitudes so deeply entrenched in the Democrat Party when it was most costly. He deserves credit for moving them forward.
The racists 50 years ago tended to be more angry and vocal than the majority of the America people at the time who were ready for healthy changes. When TV showed the brutal actions of Bull Connor, the VAST majority of Americans in the 60s were outraged and horrified.
Report comment to moderator
This looks very interesting. I’ll have to try it when it comes out on DVD.
I agree with Becky that there is one race, the human race. Skin colour (on which artificial race distinction is often based) is produced by melanocytes in the skin. These specialized cells produce the pigment (melanin) which protects from the sun. Everyone has about the same number of melanocytes in their skin; just some people’s melanocytes, because of genetics, produce more pigment. Tragic that such an insignificant difference was used to justify such cruelty.
Report comment to moderator
I think I may see this movie. I also second what Tammy stated concerning the apple dumpling gang.
I also agree with the statement that there is only one race. Just looking at my cousins, bros and I, you have every color of the rainbow, yet all look very much related.
Being the product of an inter-ethnic marriage, the only real difference between said marriage and a same ethnicity marriage is you also have to deal with culture clash. My parents have been married for over two decades and they still occasionally deal with said culture clash, though not with each other but rather the extended family. What is an insult in one culture can be an offense in another, and on occasion the two get mixed up.
Report comment to moderator
(Warning: The film does contain a lot of vulgar language.)
Report comment to moderator
I wonder if it is only the white women who use most of the vulgar language. I highly doubt it because part of Hollywood’s agenda is to legitimaze and mainstream vulgarity.
Report comment to moderator
Hollywood has long been skilled at righteously demonizing certain groups of their choosing. They do not have to make things up to demonize an unprotected group either because evil is real among all human groups in history and currently.
Report comment to moderator
back to topJoin The Conversation
You need to be a registered user of WORLDmag.com's Community section to "join the conversation."
If you are not a member yet, what are you waiting for? Register / Login Now!