Peril in Pennsylvania
Co-authored by Bob Morrison.
Last year, we saw a major push back from the election results of the previous year.
In Madison, Wis., public employees occupied the state capitol for weeks to protest Gov. Scott Walker’s not unreasonable requirement that they contribute more to their own pension funds. For his efforts to bring Wisconsin back from the brink (he’s required to balance his budget), Walker is facing a union-backed recall effort. In my home state of Ohio, Gov. John Kasich’s modest attempt to bring spending in line was rebuffed by voters in a referendum.
We can also see peril in Pennsylvania as a part of this concerted effort by liberals. But in the Keystone State the left attacked Gov. Tom Corbett through one of his aides: Robert Patterson was forced to resign from the Department of Public Welfare because, as the liberal press would have it, he edits a conservative journal called The Family in America.
Most offensive to the media was an article in the journal suggesting that there are benefits for married women to not use contraception. But the oddest thing in the liberal pack journalists’ attack on Patterson and his publication was that the article they denounced was based on the findings of evolutionary psychologists and was originally published in Scientific American. It’s apparently fine for Darwinian naturalists to research and publish in secular journals, but if conservatives dare to quote them, they’ll be hounded out of office.
To the left, it’s fine if Penn State University Press publishes the works on French feminist author Simone de Beauvoir. Pennsylvania taxpayers subsidize that university press, but they pay nothing for Patterson’s journal, a highly respected source of research and writing about important public policy issues.
Beauvoir is a major figure in feminism, but she famously came out against a woman’s right to choose. That is, women should not have the right to choose marriage and family because too many women would make that choice.
Beauvoir and her long-time companion, Jean-Paul Sartre, were leading lights of the French school of philosophy known as existentialism. In politics, both Beauvoir and Sartre were apologists for Josef Stalin.
So, let’s review. In Pennsylvania, you can be a Stalinist and have your works published by the state university press, underwritten by taxpayers, and that’s OK. But if you privately publish a journal that shows the benefits that many women receive from freely choosing marriage and family, you can be driven from your public position.
Note, I am not arguing that PSU Press should be prevented from publishing admiring analyses of Beauvoir’s work. And I am not arguing that tenured professors at Pennsylvania’s public universities should not be allowed to teach what they want to teach about Beauvoir’s philosophy.
I am showing the hypocrisy of the left. Liberals are forever claiming victim status whenever elected governors or legislators try to trim state budgets. But they are the first to attack conservatives in public positions and seek to drive them and their ideas out of the public square.
In this case, the publisher of a respected, scholarly journal was driven from office because liberals don’t like the idea of women freely choosing marriage and family, and childbirth over contraception. Liberals want to protect you and me from such a peril in Pennsylvania, and this suppression of ideas is not new in the Keystone State.
Six years ago, a photo in a brochure published by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court showed a famous Violet Oakley mural behind the justices in the courtroom. Oakley’s painting, titled The Decalogue, depicts Moses chiseling out the Ten Commandments with the text of the commandments inscribed below. But the politically correct crowd in Pennsylvania decided to deliberately blur the text in the brochure’s photo, wanting to obliterate any knowledge of the source of our laws and our ideas of justice.
Ironically, liberals were willing to censor the work of a famous female artist. Oakley’s murals in the Pennsylvania State House may be one of the first instances of a woman painter being so honored.
Bob Patterson is just the latest victim of political correctness.

















Click to Print
Include Comments











back to top20 Comments to “Peril in Pennsylvania”
The left are acting like thugs. If they do not get their way, they will use the old personal destuction attacks. Which they have master over the years.
Report comment to moderator
I am showing the hypocrisy of the left. Liberals are forever claiming victim status whenever elected governors or legislators try to trim state budgets. But they are the first to attack conservatives in public positions and seek to drive them and their ideas out of the public square.
–
Wait for 2012 … this will be on display as Obama, Union thugs, baby killers, Geroge Soros and other of the far left launch one attack after another.
Report comment to moderator
Patterson was not forced to resign. He resigned after his request to continue to edit the journal while working full time for the state was denied. Essentially he was not allowed to moonlight and thus he decided he prefer the journal over gov’t work. He could have kept the job but he decided not to resign his post as editor. Personally if I’m a taxpayer in Penn and someone’s getting paid over 100K, I wouldn’t want him editing a journal on the side. Sure the left raised a fuss about his social views but he was already hired and didn’t have to resign.
A top aide in Pennsylvania’s Department of Public Welfare quit rather than give up his outside job as editor of a conservative journal, officials said Wednesday.
Robert W. Patterson resigned this week from his $104,000-a-year job after Gov. Tom Corbett’s administration rejected his request to continue moonlighting as editor of the journal called The Family in America, a position he has held since 2009.
http://www.pennlive.com/midstate/index.ssf/2012/01/pennsylvania_department_of_pub_1.html
Report comment to moderator
I recommend the following article by Dennis Prager, titled
“They Have Islamist Fanatics, We Have Secularist Fanatics”
Link:
http://www.jewishworldreview.com/0112/prager.php3
Report comment to moderator
Patterson was pressured and essentially forced to resign. He did so after his reasonable request to continue to edit his journal was unjustly denied. The hypocrisy on the left is staggering.
The notion of having other jobs or fulfilling tasks in addition to one’s public job is often embraced for leftists. It was never shown or proven that Patterson was not or could not fulfill his job’s requirements. Such thuggery on the left is ridiculous and all too pervasive in America today.
Report comment to moderator
the Republican Governor’s administration rejected his request and then he resigned. Is Gov. Corbett a leftist??
Report comment to moderator
The word “Republican” (like mosty good labels) is often meaningless, HRW. He may be a leftist but I don’t think that “labels” bring us to a better understanding of much of anything that is political these days. The fact is, Christian principle and practice is under attack and too many decent people are intimidated. The double standard is real.
Worse than being a “leftist”, maybe Gov. Corbett is an easy-to-intimidate Republican.
Report comment to moderator
Well, we obviously can’t have a government official who advocates the only societal pattern for family operation that has ever shown long-term success anywhere in the world. He’s outta there!
Report comment to moderator
JM – maybe Gov. Corbett is an easy-to-intimidate Republican.
I wish that statement didn’t make me think of Mitt Romney.
Report comment to moderator
HRW, before offering opinions, it’s best to know all the facts. Mr. Patterson was hired for this job with the understanding that he could continue editing the journal he was associated with. When the Inquirer made threats about publishing a negative piece about the welfare recommendations, Mr. Patterson was told that agreement was rescinded. Even if he had agreed to quit being the editor, it would not have changed the outcome – the Inquirer wanted him gone and the Governor was scared stiff so was pleased with the “resignation.” This is not the end of the story. It’s likely that others in that administration will meet the same end at the “request” of the Inquirer. Is this what our country has come to – being at the mercy of the media?
Report comment to moderator
BJCOOKE – Thanks for the “inside information”. It sounds like that newspaper should change its name to the “Philadelphia Inquisitor”.
Report comment to moderator
Public figures have always been at the mercy of the press.
The sources I have read state he was hired on October 31st and resigned after his request to continue working elsewhere was denied. The request to continue work elsewhere is standard for any new employee and there’s no guarantee it will be approved. It may be that the he had unofficial assurances before he took the job and then was turned down officially. There’s also a chance that this decision was influenced by the press, but the fact remains that the actual events are different than described in this column. Not only that, but the column and comment 10 are poorly sourced.
Report comment to moderator
The American Family, may have been founded by, and is edited by a fellow named Alan Carlson.
From Wikipedia:
>i>Rockford Institute is a conservative think-tank associated with paleoconservatism, based in Rockford, Illinois.[1] It is known for the John Randolph Club, and publishes Chronicles: A Magazine of American Culture.
It was founded by Rockford College President John A. Howard in 1976 as a response to American social changes of the 1960s. Allan Carlson served as president until 1997. He left with John Howard to found The Howard Center for Family, Religion & Society, on offshoot of the Rockford Institute.[1] They took with them two publications: Religion and Society Report and Family in America. Thomas Fleming, editor of Chronicles, succeeded Carlson as president.[1]
The institute and Lutheran pastor Richard John Neuhaus invited Cardinal Ratzinger to give a lecture in New York in January 1988.[2] On May 5, 1989, Neuhaus and his Religion and Society Center were evicted from the institute’s New York office after he complained about what he said were “the racist and anti-Semitic tones” of the institute’s Chronicles magazine.[1][3] The charge, which was supported by other leading conservatives, was denied by the institute.[4] They said the office, called Rockford East, was closed for budgetary reasons and because of concerns that Neuhaus was not following institute policies.[4] According to political commentator David Frum, the split was seen by leading conservatives as a sign of the division between the paleoconservative and the neo-conservative elements of the movement.[5]
It also seems that Dr Carlson earned his degree, not in demographics or sociology or even theology, but in European history. How that qualifies him to edit what World here calls a “respected scholarly journal” on the American Family, remains a mystery to me. But then again, so does a lot that goes on in the neo-paleo-ghenghis con world.
Report comment to moderator
I was introduced to Chronicles by a young Libertarian. He gave me a subscription as a gift. When it came time to renew I was torn. I hate that magazine! I also love that magazine! Overtly (or even covertly racist)? Of course not. But joyously eclectic, offbeat, and politically “incorrect”. Good writing that is thought-provoking in many areas where I don’t particularly want to be provoked. Christian? One article will be a practical defense of Christianity. The next three might be purely secular, or even anti-Christian. Those who see no need for critical thinking, should be very afraid of Chronicles!
Report comment to moderator
Even Bernanke said yesterday that the govt. has to get the fiscal business under control or the country fails.
So, maybe that’s what it will take.
Public employees should not be able to hold the rest of us hostage.
Report comment to moderator
HRW, check your sources. I actually have mine from the “horse’s mouth.” AND, don’t believe everything you read, especially in the media of today. In fact, Mr. Patterson has the official letter, signed and delivered, giving him that permission. Until the Inquirer dug deep was it rescinded hoping to protect the Governor himself, not his employees. Watch for an op-ed to be printed by the Inquirer on Monday (I believe) by Mr. Patterson himself. Maybe then you’ll realize that what you read (especially in the public sector media) never guarantees the whole story. Journalism today by the liberal media is slanted their way. They are not in it to simply state the facts. Hopefully, you won’t have to learn this the hard way!
Report comment to moderator
“the Republican Governor’s administration rejected his request and then he resigned. Is Gov. Corbett a leftist?? ”
No, but Republicans can be cowards, too. He’s the one who knuckled under to pressure, but it’s the fact that there’s pressure on someone for something like this that’s the sign of incipient leftism.
Report comment to moderator
“Last year, we saw a major push back from the election results of the previous year.”
Another way to say this is — A lot of people are having buyers remorse.
The squeaky wheel is getting all the oil in Wis. right now, while the other wheels are silent. My feel is that the vast majority approve of the Governors actions.
See what happens when a balanced budjet is law? The makers are taxed enough, the takers can’t get enough. But in Wis. enoughs, enough.
Report comment to moderator
“budget” good grief
Report comment to moderator
HRW, if you look at what created the outcry for his termination, it wasn’t that he wasn’t doing his job – it was that, while working as Dept. of Public Welfare aide, a journal he copy-edited re-printed an article suggesting that there are benefits for women in not using contraception – an article that was originially published in Scientific American.
Report comment to moderator
back to topJoin The Conversation
You need to be a registered user of WORLDmag.com's Community section to "join the conversation."
If you are not a member yet, what are you waiting for? Register / Login Now!